Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

I wear size 9.5. I tried on this style in 2 different colors, the black and rose gold. The rose gold size 9 pair felt larger (and made my feet look larger) than my 9.5 black nubuck pair. I that that was odd. Both felt extremely comfortable. I'm sticking with the black ones.... classic look that can be dressed up or casual, comfortable, easy to slip on...can't beat Sperry.

I love these. I was shopping for a patent loafer and this was the pair. I think I'll get a second pair just because I love them so much. And maybe another color too! Comfortable, no difficulty breaking in. I wear them without socks, and my feet are no more sweaty than with my usual ballet flats.

Super cute, particularly if you have a thinner foot. Definitely needed to go up 1/2 size. Looks great with everything.

I want these in every color!! They feel snug when you first put them on. Don’t worry because they will stretch and mold to your foot and become your favorite shoes.

Very comfortable - with great arch support.

Perfect fit! Wow! Soglad may order more!!

Very pleased with the quality and style. Very snug fit at first, but after a week, show started to loosen up. May cause the top of your foot to blister initially, but you feet will get accustomed to it.

I initially ordered these in a size 11, and they were way too big (I wear a size 11 in most shoes, 11.5 in Rothy's and running shoes). Unfortunately, Sperry doesn't make half-sizes one you get above a 10, so I returned and ordered down a full size. Now they're too small (hence the docked comfort star) but I feel confident that once I wear them a lot and try to stretch them a little, they'll be super comfy. The tan ones do have a slightly masculine aesthetic, which I wasn't expecting when I ordered them, but I've decided I like it. Please make half-sizes!