Customer Reviews Cole Haan Piper Mule

With all the positive reviews and the pointed toe style I was looking for, I was convinced I was going to love these - maybe my arch is too low or rolls in, but these were immediately uncomfortable on the inside edges of my feet. Could immediately feel the inner edges of the shoe, and was uncomfortable immediately not just after a time. One of those “this is going to give me a blister in the first hour” kind of uncomfortable. Except for that, they felt pretty comfortable, so maybe works for people with high arches. Left shoe also came the pointed toe already nicked

too wide i wish they came in narrow. i have very narrow feet

I am probably just a mule klutz, but I couldn't keep them on while walking and needed them for a wedding -- felt like I was going to spend too much time focused on that rather than the even. It really may a case of "it's me, not you".

VERY cute. I really wanted to like and keep these, but my toes were very pinched/squished to where I felt like I would have blisters after just a few minutes of walking. My feet are very much on the narrow side, so I was surprised as I don't have this issue with any other shoes I have in similar styles.

Sleek shoe, I liked the material and style! It does run small, though.

These were so cute, and I wanted them to work. But my feet just didn’t feel “secure” and I had to walk with the intention of keeping them on. I was wearing a mule sock which had grippies on its bottom. Without socks, it rubbed my pinky toes. Had to send back.

Fit was good I ordered a half size larger. Did not feel I was sent a new shoe! Not in original box that was over sized! Not even wrapped professionally! Leads me to believe this is why shoe was on sale! Should have been marked down even more! Still considering returning them. Cole Han would have been ashamed in packaging!

Item was much too small.

Runs small like all Cole Haan shoes... Leather was not soft or buttery. I expected more from this brand.

VERY pointy toe! Felt like a witch's shoe... not for me!

Very noisy & squeaky. They were everything I wanted, fit well, but made so much noise when I walked it was comical. So disappointed.

Unwearable. Zero support

Although I liked the shoes, they completely broke apart after ~15-20 wears (the interior ripped, the sole unattached, and the shoes look like they have been work for years); can't wear them anymore. Really disappointing since this was a quite expensive pair of shoes from Cole Haan, which normally makes high quality items

Poor quality. Wore once, metallic began to rub off and top seam ripped.