Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gigi

Bought this sandal for the first time about 3 or 4 years ago and wore them until they were beat, and they still looked good! The ankle strap stretched out over time because I don't bother to unbuckle the sandal each time. Just bought a replacement pair, they go with everything - casual shorts/jeans as well as summer dresses.

I am a size 8, but noticed that a lot of the other reviews said that they needed a 1/2 size bigger so I ordered an 8 1/2...it was too big. I returned them and got an 8. Yay!

First, the rose dust is absolutely gorgeous. I usually wear an 8½ in flats/9 in heels, and have narrow feet. So, I ordered both the 8½ and 9 in the GiGi. Both are very narrow, and there is not much difference between the two sizes in terms of width. I liked that I had a bit more length at the top of my toes with the 9. but when I walked my feet moved around too much within the size 9. These are minimalist sandals, so I want what little strappy support there is to be secure. Overall, The 8½ fits very well. I just wish they were a tiny bit longer. I think this is part of the style, though. The sandals showcase the feet and sort of hides out under them. I can see the stitching and sandal at the top of my toes and they are very comfortable and cute, so I kept the 8½ and returned the 9. I also bought three other colors!

I was hoping to have the lucky foot but sadly like most everyone else these were slightly a hair too small. I'm a 7-7.5 but ordered these 7.5. I'm getting an 8 fingers crossed! Here's my good deed for the year the measurements for 7.5 (length edge to edge 10-1/8; width 3-5/8) Hope it helps!

The Gigi is awesome because the back strap as a little elastic that makes it easy to slip on and off without dealing with the buckle. My last pair went about a year or so before the elastic broke, but given the price I wasn't too upset. I normally wear a 10 but ordered a 9.5 and they fit fine (although I imagine a 10 would fit as well if not better).

Woah, these sandals are PERFECT! Now that I own a pair of Gigis, I don't see my closet ever being without this specific style of Sam Edelman shoe. So versatile, comfortable, adorable, durable...yes, all the -able words I can think of apply to these little gems! I'm in love (can you tell?), and I'm not afraid to shout it to the world! Or just the Zappos community. Saddle was my color of choice simply because the others were a little bold for my first shot at a shoe I wasn't sure I'd like. Literally, I haven't taken the shoes off since trying them on out of the box. We're inseparable and make a great team. Go get yourself a pair of Sam Edelman Gigi sandals! Trust me!

Love this shoe. Great quality and looks amazing. I couldn't figure out what size to order, though, based on other reviews claiming it ran small. I'm normally an 8 so I ordered an 8. It fits perfectly, though my toes are closer to the end of the shoe than in other sandals. Here's what I recommend: if you typically run between sizes (i.e., sometimes an 8 and sometimes an 8 1/2), then I would order the 8 1/2. But, if you are always a solid 8, then you will be fine ordering the 8.

OMG....I love these sandals! They are so comfy and look super attractive on my long narrow foot. Bought 2 pairs and would like more. I love to wear them with maxi dresses! Beware if you have a wide foot these may not work for you and I also ordered a 1/2 size up. These may be the best sandal ever!

Great sandal that I bought for a summer Europe trip. Haven't worn them much so hopefully my feet fare well in them, but they have felt comfortable so far. Bought them at the recommendation of a blog about what to wear for comfort and style in Paris! I tried them on in a department store before ordering and definitely needed a half size up. I am 7 1/2 and the 8 fits perfectly (I could barely buckle the 7 1/2s). I bought both the plain black leather and a more vivid color combination on sale. I know they'll look even more fabulous when I get my long overdue pedicure! As usual, amazing service from Zappos.

Love the way these look, but they are narrow. Not enough of an issue to return them though!

I love these sandals. These are my 5th pair of Gigi's. They are easy to wear and for me very comfortable. I really like the color -blocked ones they go great with everything. I want to get the silver ones when they come back in stock. Can't forget to mention the great service Zappos provide, next day delivery is awesome! Thanks!

Fantastic summer sandal! Cute, comfortable and well made. I would recommend ordering a half size larger. I am normally an 8, and the 8.5 fit perfectly. Highly recommend these sandals.

Do what every review says. Buy a half size larger! I'm always a perfect 10. I listened to reviews and got 10.5 and it fits perfect! Great shoe. Great quality. I can see new colors in the future, but I'm sure this shoe will go with everything for a very long time. Thanks Zappos! You never let me down.

Adorable! Wear 4.5 but ordered a 4! Foot bed is just fine in length, with buckle being on first hole but feel this will stretch. Could wear either size so glad to get these before gone!

These are super cute and extremely comfortable. I really like the padded soles as that allows for longer wear. The shoes are a bit more vibrant in person than online. While this was my first Sam Edelman purchase, it will not be my last. This shoe runs small so size up half a size.

Ready to wear out of the box and comfy and did not need to break them in. These are a favorite most days this summer. Went a half size up because I have wider feet and felt more comfortable in them.

Very beautiful and comfortable sandal. Matches perfectly with the outfit I want to wear them with. There are many color combinations in this shoe.

I love these flats! I ordered them in hopes of getting summer flats that would be a staple and I got just that! They footbed is padded and I love how comfortable they are to wear! Worth the cost! I plan on ordering them in more colors!

Beautiful, vibrant color! Runs small. I had to order 1 size larger for my daughter from 9 to 10. I also own a pair of Gigi's in size 12, my usual size is 11.

I love these sandals. The color is a perfect nude and is very versatile. I normally wear an 8 1/2 or 9. The 9 fit perfectly. I would definitely order up a size if in doubt.

My go to summer sandals! They are versatile and can be dressed down or up. I normally wear a size 7 in most shoes but got these in a 7 1/2 (my normal Sam Edelman size). My toes were right at the edge in the 7s. I have wide feet and feel that these sandals keep my feet in and they don't look or feel narrow. I have these in many colors and love them all. Extremely comfortable for flats. I wear them to work all day with no troubles and no blisters. Highly recommend these!

Wonderful, basic sandal for everyday use. Works with shorts, pants and dresses. Elegant but not prissy. Comfortable, but no arch support (not expected in a sandal of this type).

Great looking sandal & so comfy. Also great price for the quality. Love these & will get them in many colors & live in them this summer.

Love this beautifully made sandal. Gorgeous color combination and very comfortable. I ordered this in a 7 based on reviews. I wear a 6.5. No regrets.

I absolutely adore these sandals. When I got them in the mail they were great, the only thing was my toes touched the top of the sandal barely (I ordered my normal size). They are so cute. I love them so much!