Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Stillson

I always wear a size 7 but these were too small so I’ll have to return. Very pretty and stylish, though.

Many people said to go down a size (I'm normally a 7.5 and I ordered a 7) and they were too small. Wish I could write my review based on a pair that fit properly, but so be it. I am deciding not to keep these but mainly because I don't like the toe - it's way too rounded for me. I prefer a pointier toe ... I think they just look more professional (bought these for work - I work in a big law firm). While they were small and I think would have been better a half size up, I'm not super sure about comfort ... material felt pretty stiff and I have a feeling even the right size would have been a bit uncomfortable.

This shoe is beautiful - and the square heel is easier on the foot than a pointed/stiletto style heel. I wear a 7 - and wish I had ordered a 7 1/2 to have some space to put one of those pillow-y foot pads in the front of the shoe. I could use a little more cushion for comfort.

Got the wide in my normal size and it was too big. Sized down and after breaking it in a little just wearing it around the house, was too big again. The shoe itself is gorgeous but not sure if I can wear it if the heel just slips off my foot. Wonder if it's just an issue with the wide shoe?

Gorgeous shoe, but didn't fit right. I'm usually a 6 or 5.5 in pumps. The size 6 was a little too long - it left a small space between my heel and the back of the shoe. Then I tried the 5.5 and could barely squeeze my foot in. It felt more like a 5 .

Gorgeous shoe! I wanted to love and keep, but the 8 was too small, and the 8.5 was too big. I have a high arch, so I’m not sure if that had anything to do with it. Sam Edelman’s are my go-to for boots and heels, so I’m sad these gorgeous shoes didn’t work out.

I only wore these shoes for about 10 minutes around the house but they seemed fairly comfortable as heels go but I had to return them based on the color. If you have golden undertones in your skin and/or are tan, they'd be fine but if you have very fair skin (like me) then they look more tan instead of nude.

Cute comfy heel but seems to run half size too large

I love the shape of this shoe, but it's a bit high. I ended up ordering wide for comfort, but wish I sized down .5 to make the fit a little better. (Wore them out of the house before giving them a good test run.) Overall a nice staple to any wardrobe. Quality is very nice.

Love the color, but just not wide enough. I will continue to look for a shoe that fits in a neutral color.

I SO want to love these. The style is cute and the block heel is comfortable. That said, they do feel extremely narrow. My foot does tend to run a bit to the wide side of a medium, but it's normally not an issue. These shoes squeeze the sides of my feet, and so far I've only been able to make it through 1 work day wearing them the entire time. Unfortunately, by the time I figured that out I had worn them and was unable to return. I'll probably end up purchasing another pair in the wide width and seeing if I have the same problem, because I do love the style!

They aren’t that comfortable but look very cute. Will be wearing them indoors at work only.

These are BEAUTIFUL shoes, but unfortunately, not comfortable enough to keep. I am between size 8 – 8.5 and based on other reviews stating to order a half-size down, I ended up ordering the 8. Even with a small bunion on my right foot, I don’t normally require wide-width shoes so I ordered normal-width. The length of the shoe was perfect; however, the toe box was too tight, stretching directly across my right foot mini-bunion and I just can’t imagine myself being comfortable enough to wear around the office or for a night out. Sadly, I returned.

I wanted these shoes to fit so much!! I got the red suede and they were beautiful!!! But.... the heel was a bit higher than I was expecting, and they cut into my feet on the inside. They felt true to size-- they weren't tight, just that the edge was stiff and hit the edge of my foot at the bone. So disappointed!

The wide is not a true wide and the toe box was digging into my foot. That doesn’t happen with most wide shoes that I order, except Naturalizer, which often has the same problem (not a true wide). The style is attractive and I was disappointed that they didn’t fit. Given the price and poor fit I could not give these a high rating or recommend them to anyone with a wide foot.

Cute but too high of a heel to be comforabtle for me.

The problem was that the seam hit right at my left bunion so immediately as I put them on, it hurt. That's more about my bunion than the shoe, but might be useful information if you have bunions.

I should’ve listened to the other reviews. I wear a size 8 and I ordered a size 8. My left foot came completely out of the shoe the right fit OK but pinch so badly across the ball of my foot that there was no way I could wear it. They are beautiful shoes. But beware order one half size down. Sorry but they have to go back!

I normally wear an 8 and the fit was fine. The heel was too tall and a bit of toe cleavage so I returned them.

Found this shoe VERY uncomfortable and seemed cheaply made in my opinion.

Super cute shoe, however it was super stiff in the ball of the foot so I returned them. I ordered the leopard print and it was just as the picture shows.

These are really nice looking shoes and the height is great, but they are way too narrow for my only-slightly-wide feet. It would be nice if there were wide choices available in more than basic black and blue. Very disappointing.