Customer Reviews UGG Classic Short Waterproof

These boots are super warm and seem to be good quality. They fit similar to most of my other Uggs, except they do run shorter than the classic Uggs (width seems normal); I think it is because the shearling is so thick on these. I usually wear a 9 in Uggs and the 9.5 felt a little tight, but I know from experience that the shearling will compress and the 10 would be too big after a couple of wearings. They are comfortable and will definitely keep my feet warm and dry. They probably wouldn't be great for doing a lot of walking because they don't hold your foot in place well, that is my heel lifts up as I walk. My only complaint is that the leg opening is rather large and looks a little ridiculous if you have skinny ankles/calves like I do. This also means that these do not work well if you are walking through loose snow because the snow can easily come up and over the top of the boot as you walk.

I usually wear a 9W in Clarks, Earth, Naturalizer, etc. I bought these in a 10 since wides are not available in UGGs. The length was just right and toe bo did not squeeze my wide forefoot. However, I also have high arches. There just was not enough volume in that area of the boot to accommodate my foot. I was afraid to wear them in hopes that stretching would take place since the tight area was at a seam line. These are great looking boots for wearing in snow country. I wish they had fit. Thanks to Zappos for fast delivery and free returns.

When I first bought the 9s I was nervous because one was so tight my foot felt numb. I knew from the previous purchase that the 9.5 was too big. I took the insole out and flattened it by hand and wore the shoe for 3 days and it’s perfect now. Also it is truely deep-puddle water proof. No winter salt stains! I ran back and forth with my kids in them and I do not find them to be heavy.

In addition to the waterproofing, there is a definite difference between these Uggs and the Classic Uggs, which they are modeled after. As a city winter boot, these are not bad, but they feel heavier and clunkier to walk in than the Classic (non-waterproof) style. The also run narrower and are snugger on the instep, yet the circumference is about an inch wider than the classic boot. My impression is that they will not stretch out as much, or not as fast, but they are less comfortable for me out of the box. Haven't yet decided which pair i will keep. Thank you, Zappos, for the chance to consider both options!

The grey definitely runs small, I ordered a half size up and it fit perfectly! I decided I would rather have black though, so I returned the grey 8.5 for a black 8.5 and the black one was too big! I ordered the black in an 8, which is my usual size, and it fit perfectly. So, in my experience, the grey runs a half size small and the black runs true to size.

I took other reviewers advice and ordered a half size up. I definitely recommend doing that because my normal size would have been too small. It is slightly larger in the heel area, however not enough of an issue to return.

I had originally ordered my normal size 5.5 but was too small & narrow so then ordered size 6 which slips a bit on the heel but I will adjust as I love the boot. I only gave 4 stars as the price of this boot should guarantee a true to size fit. I would have also preferred the sole be a bit thinner as the thicker sole makes it a bit clunky for walking.

Bought these for my wife and she ended up returning them and getting the Bailey Button style. These seem to run more narrow than other Ugg boots. The sole is slightly more ridged and she said she felt the arch more in these compared to the others.

I normally wear the size 9 in the classic boot and with these I had to go up a full size to a 10 in order to fit. I was specifically shopping for a rubber sole for the icy winter. I chose these over the Ugg ultra short revival due to the better non-skid sole and wideness of the boot. However, next to each other these boots didn't seem as "black" and they are firm/molded across the foot and side of the boot. They appear to be clean cut, and not your typical slouchy Ugg boots. Because of that I am not sure how they will wear, but they did fit my wide foot, whereas the Ugg ultra short revival boot was super narrow and they didn't work out.

Like these a lot! Love that they’re waterproof and I don’t have to bother spraying them like I always did with the Bailey Buttons. Huge plus. I’m still getting used to them because I’ve always gotten the Bailey Buttons and there are def some differences, but I really do like them. Warm, comfy, waterproof, and the special skids on the bottom do help some on the ice for sure. Not much arch support, but pretty comfy soles. In the Bailey Buttons, I’m always an 8, which is what I ordered first. Returned for an 8.5 and they fit perfect. Recommend ordering half size larger. If you’re planning to wear big bulky socks, go a full size up.