Customer Reviews Merrell Emma Leather

So I have awful super flat feet and wear orthotics. I have to have just the right shoe for my orthotics and comfort. After trying on like almost a dozen pair of shoes (from really good shoe makers, by the way), this was the only one that fit the bill. They are amazingly comfortable, my orthotics fit perfectly (I didn't even have to size up), and absolutely no break-in time. And, they look terrific with slacks and jeans! Thank you, Merrell. I've been wearing Merrells for years and I can always count on them.

I usually wear a size 7, but after reading many reviews about this style running small, I ordered a 7.5. I’m really glad I did, otherwise I think my toes would have been rubbing. The shoe is comfortable with a medium weight sock. The reason I gave a 4 star for overall is the leather has a “v” on the top edge by the ankle. I think from the cardboard insert. I’m hoping this will relax out after wearing. I’m hoping this will be a stylish but comfortable walking shoe. I am a fan of Merrell shoes. This is my first time ordering from Zappos and I was pleased with the price and the service.

Love the classic clog sole with the stylish higher instep. Ordered a half size up based on reviews and I’m glad I did but my heel slips a bit. Works well with no-show socks.

I bought this shoe in both the black and the brown, and I am usually a very standard 8.5M. The brown shoes were too small, about a half size too small, but the black version fit. So I'm returning the brown. Seems like a nice sturdy but lightweight shoe otherwise.

Comfortable foot bed but I think the leather uppers seemed easily scratchable. I have a pair of Dansko clogs which I tend to sprain my ankle in and I was hoping it was the brand, not the style that tended to cause that but after trying in these I've concluded it must be the style. No clogs for me I guess.

I tried two sizes: my regular size 10 and a half size larger 10.5. The 10.5 definitely was a better fit, but the shoe was still too narrow. These are very comfortable and stylish for clogs. If you have a narrower foot, this is a great shoe.

I wish these had fit me. If the leather had been a little softer (it's very hard, like a clog), maybe they'd have stretched enough to fit my wide feet and need for a large toe box. But I have to return them. The quality is very good, and the style and height would have been perfect for my needs.

Really liked the look and feel of the shoe. According to the Merrell size chart I wear a 10.5. It was too small so had to send them back. I love Merrell shoes in general, they last and look great.

Very cute, way too small though. Normally wear a 9, & 9.5 is too small. Re-ordering in a 10.

Sooo small that I couldn’t even get my foot all the way in. I never at any time have worn a 9 1/2, but I think that’s what I’d have to buy, after attempting to put on this shoe. I’m so disappointed

These are beautiful, but I was unable to keep them - they run very small, and VERY narrow. I ordered up 1/2 size as reviews suggested, but don't think even adding a full size would compensate for the narrow toe area. Bummer, because they look very comfortable, and cute. C'mon Merrell - let's have shoes for chubby-footed people!

I love the style of this shoe, but they were just too narrow. I usually wear a wide, but since I was able to wear the Merrell Jungle with a regular width, I thought these might fit. So disappointed.

I paid attention to the reviews and ordered a half size up. They were so small I couldn’t get my feet into them. Returning.

I generally like Merrell clogs, and wear an 8.5 or 9, but this 9 was too snug (with socks.) For me, the heel is a bit too high (I usually go with a slightly lower heel) but would work for others. The finish is quite casual, and even if it fit, I might have returned it due to that, since I need it for work. I also tried a Merrell Encore Kassie Buckle Slide, which was exactly the same size but too large. Go figure.

I normally wear a 7 to 7.5. I read these run small so I ordered a 7.5. Way too small. Then ordered an 8 - again way too small. I think these are really cute, so I plan on ordering an 8.5 and a 9. Hopefully one of these will work. Order at least a full size larger than what you typically wear.

I have a pair of Merrell's that I use for tradeshows - they're not super stylish but they are totally functional for standing on a cement floor for 8 hours a day. I decided to get a second pair of Merrell's and the original style I have no longer exists. WOW these are so much smaller. I could barely get my foot inside. Going back.

I love the look of this shoe, but for my left foot, it was just too narrow, putting pressure on a bunion, and also I have a high arch and there was too much pressure on the top of the foot.

This shoe does not work for my feet. My feet are a medium width across the ball of the foot and narrowish in the heel, and this shoe slipped at the heel. I would not have been able to keep them on my feet.

Runs narrow and small. I have wide feet, so I usually order a half size larger to compensate. I'm returning these and having to order a full size up. I hope they work because I finally found a style and arch support I like.

Wow... these were WAY too small. I ordered a half-size up, but should have ordered a full-size for full-size and a half size up. Regardless, I was not happy with the overall look of the leather; not an even tone. I thought it would be more of a suede look, but it was dull and blotchy.

Clunky looking shoe with tight fit around the front of foot.

These run REALLY small. I ordered one size larger and they didn't come close to fitting.

NARROW! I wear 8 or 8.5 and ordered one pair of each. I tried on the 8.5, and they are very narrow. I wore them around home hoping they'd break in (the leather seems soft enough), and after a half hour of just sitting at my desk I had to take them off due to the pain. The length is accurate, and the heel is plenty wide. I don't know whether or not I'll try the 9 but I've got to return these.