Customer Reviews Massimo Matteo Pointy Toe Pump 17

This shoe is a show stopper!! It's absolutely gorgeous, unfortunately I sized down as a few reviews suggested - bad idea for me. I ordered a 6 and I'm usually a 6.5, the 6 was painfully tight. I'll definitely try these again in a 6.5. If you're a stiletto girl this shoe in your size is for you!!

I fell in love with the look of the shoe. Very sexy. Especially the red patent heels. Like any woman's shoe with a heel of this height, walking becomes painful after only a few hours. However, the attention I get when I'm wearing them more than makes up for the pain. I can almost guarantee a romantic evening with my husband will follow when I have these on. It goes without saying that all men love this shoe and wish their significant other had a pair.

They are beautiful and seem comfortable but quite small, at least a half size if not more. Exchanging for larger.

These shoes are really gorgeous on but because they are patent leather I knew I would want to size up. I typically wear a 6.5 so I bought the 7 and they fit well. They are pointy so the front of the shoe does have some snugness to it but it’s not painful. My feet are not narrow but I do lean toward a medium to narrow width. For me, this snug fit helps keep the heel on when I walk which is something I always struggle with. The height of the heel gives this shoe a sexy profile without having to wear 5” heels, too! I wore these shoes at work for over 10 hours and didn’t feel the need to take them off half way during the day. I have fibromyalgia and as I’ve gotten older my feet can’t tolerate cheaply made shoes. I’ve returned more shoes than I’ve kept because the pain is too much but I refuse to start wearing flats at only 44 years old so if I can wear them, you probably could too ??

They need to make a 1/4 size for these shoes. They are just a little too small. Stretching them out is hopefully going to help them be perfect shoes.

Beautiful shoe. However, the color is nothing like the pictures online which is disappointing. The color is a very light nude and looks nothing like the pictures.

Beautiful navy pumps, similar to Jimmy Choo Anouk pumps. Footbed is padded which is always a bonus for heels.

I gave this 4 stars overall because I own this shoe in two other colors ( black and red patent) in my regular size of 8.5, but for some reason I could not squeeze my foot into the black patent leather shoe. I'm going to try half a size up. Based on the other shoes I own that fit properly, this is a lovely shoe and is comfortable, even for having such a high heel.

This is the second time for me trying ot these shoes. Unfortunately, even though other reviewers claim they are a half size large, they definately are at least a half size SMALL for me, This is twice now and as much as I wanted these to work, I will be returning them.

This is a beautiful shoe! I love everything about it. The heel is perfect, the leather is soft but saddly I have to return. I took the advice of others and ordered a half size down which was a 7 (I would normally wear a 7-1/2). The length of the shoe fit ok, the width is what did not work for me. I do not have a narrow foot but these shoes where wide. Maybe if I would go to a 6-1/2 it would fit better? I'll try again once the color I want is back in stock.

This shoe runs at least a 1/2 large. I normally wear a 7.5 in heels and a 7.5-8 in flats. I got a 7.5 and a 7. I’m keeping the 7. As long as they don’t stretch too much, the 7 should be good. Toe box is comfortable for a pointed shoe. If you love the look of So Kate’s, but aren’t sure about paying the $$$ these are a good starting point.

Ordered size 9 and 10. I am a size 9 and sometimes a 9 1/2. These shoes definitely fit small. Although the 10 is too large for me, I will keep them and put shoe inserts in them so my heel wont flop out. Also the 10 fits my width. I will return the 9.

These shoes are definitely not true to size. A 91/2 would fit perfect but they don’t make it in that size( I’m a 9 or 9 1/2).Initially they seem to fit but because of the heel height eventually my foot scunches to the front and then my heel flops out. I love the pencil thin heel as I never see that many heels with them. If they made this shoe in a 9 1/2 I would buy it in every color!

Upon reading the reviews I ordered 1/2 smaller size. A mistake, this heels is true to size however a bit narrow. Very frustrated with the color, on the website the Tan is more like caramel but it's a true Tan. Not a color for dark skin.

I am a true size 9 but the size 9 in this shoe is way too narrow ( can’t get my foot in it) and I will return it. I also ordered the size 10 just in case and I got it on but when I walk my heel flops. Kinda like wearing my mother’s shoes. I’m sure a size 91/2 would fit perfect but it doesn’t come in that size. I may keep the 10 because this is a beautiful shoe.

Beautiful shoe. Extremely uncomfortable - felt a whole size too small, no arch support and heel is very skinny and not sturdy. Returned.

Looks more grey than neutral

To be honest, this review is less about the shoes than it is about Zappos. These shoes have a soft suede outsole. For some unknown reason, zappos decided to put very large cheap stickers on the bottom of each shoe that don't peel off easily - instead leaving a large patch of adhesive residue. Since the outsole is soft, you can't scrape off the adhesive without damaging the shoe. So the bottom of the shoes look very ugly now with their discolored adhesive blotches, and I look forward to regularly having to clean all the dust and dirt that sticks to them. Yay. The heels are cute though I guess

Good quality

I usually wear a size 8. So I listened to the reviews and got an 7 1/2. I couldn’t squeeze my feet into them. I’m not sure if I will need my regular 8 or even an 8 1/2. But the leather is very soft and they seem like they will be comfortable for as high as a heel as they are.

While these shoes were just a tad too small, they are truly lovely! I plan on checking to see if the next half size up will work for me.

Gorgeous shoe, I have never had a sexier looking heel. I will be ordering another pair in another color. Lots of room in the toe. I typically wear a 9.5 but after reading reviews I went with a 9 and they fit perfect. Highly recommend!

Loved these and were very comfortable but the manufacturer puts a sticker on the bottom of both shoes and I know from past that it’s hard to peel them off and look clean.

I have several pairs of this show. Love, love, love them. They fit well. they are very stylish. I get many compliments. if you make it in a different color, i will buy them. Have all the colors now available. plus some that are no longer available.

I wear this heel almost everyday! I have the 3 colors. They feel great and look absolutely incredible. For a 4+ inch heel, they actually feel great. I wear them at work everyday for 8-10 hours with no problems. I wear them with dresses, skirts, dress suits and skinny jeans and they look so sexy with what ever I wear. I get compliments all the time! Buy them, wear them and love them!