Customer Reviews SAS Maria Comfort Mary Jane

This shoe gapped at the forefoot and felt wider than a regular D width.

These shoes run narrower. If you have wide feets, need to get a ww.

The fit was good, but the shoes squeaked when I walked. Can't sneak up on employees that way :)

I have wide feet, so I ordered my usual double wide. The toe box was much too narrow -- it pinched my two smallest toes. It's too bad I have to return them, because I like the style, and I think they would have been comfortable if they had fit.

I thought these were cute shoes. I have a super narrow foot. They felt great in forefoot but loose in heel, like the heel bed was short. My heels just sipped right out of the shoe when i tried them on. Sad, because they are cute.

I have horrible feet, narrow heels, bunions and severely overprotonated (flat) feet. I had high hopes for this shoe but it was too tight in toe box and I stepped out of the heel.

These were extremely too narrow- I got the medium. My feet are not generally wide, either.

The shoes are really well made and the style is better than most mary janes. But the sizing was off for me. I need a wide toe box for bunions but my heel is narrow/regular sized. My usual size is 5.5W, which were too long. I then tried a 5WW. The toe box felt good and accommodated my bunion. But my heels were slipping out, even with the strap on the tightest hole. I've noticed this problem generally in SAS shoes in W or WW - too wide in the heel, needs more room in the toe box. I gave up on these and returned them.

Love the style, however, they were not the shoe to wear on long 12 hour days. Great quality just not the comfort I needed.

Love the looks of this shoe, have tried to wear them, but the shoe puts a lot of pressure on bunion. So that is why I’m returning.

Pretty shoe, but for a Narrow, the heel fit is just too wide.

I wear a 10.5 narrow, which is almost impossible to find. So, I typically go for an 11 narrow. The narrow in this shoe is too narrow in the toe box, but was great in the heel. The medium was good in the toe box, but too wide in the heel. I had to find a pair of black shoes, so kept the 11M. Style is ok and comfort was ok, except for the slipping heel. Strap across the instep helps somewhat. However, shoemakers make whole AND half sizes all the way until size 10, but anyone beyond size 10 is out of luck for a half size. What gives???

I reallllllly wanted this shoe to work for me, but unfortunately had to return them. I have very hard to fit duck feet (aka hobbit feet) and I normally wear a 7WW and found these to be a touch tight, but I think the material would probably stretch with time. I do have pretty bad bunions and the bend of the shoe painfully pressed into the top of my foot right on top of them when I walked and the heel slipped off even with the strap, so instant no go.

I really want to love these shoes because they are almost perfect. But I wear a size 5 WIDE. I received it and wear them on occasion, but they aren't a wide fit at all. They feel like just a normal sized shoe. If you have small feet but a wide footbed, and you are looking specifically for WIDE shoes because every other shoe you own is typically just too narrow, these are not the wide width you are looking for.

I have very narrow feet and in most shoes my heel slips out. That’s why I try to get shoes with straps. On this shoe, I got the Slim because I have found most narrows aren’t narrow enough in the heel. Unfortunately, my heel still slips in this shoe, and the toe box is too cramped. The shoe isn’t terrible looking, but it’s nothing too write home about.

Too narrow across the toes for my double-wide foot. Nice cushioning and arch support.

I wanted to love these, but the moment I put them on, I could feel the edge of the shoe between the strap and my toes cutting into my foot. It may be something that would get better with wear, but I knew it would be too uncomfortable, even painful, to wear long enough in hopes that would happen. So, they were returned.

Not a WW (double wide). Maybe it's marked wrong. Too tight across the toes and ball.

I usually wear a 7W or 7WW. I ordered these in 7WW but they are not very wide at all. Sorry, had to return them.

I tried this SAS because it was similar to an Aravon, which can work well for me, given how difficult my feet are to fit. However, this wide-width shoe didn't feel wide at all!

The shoe fit, but the high ankle box created a pressure point and was rubbing enough to cause a blister within less than an hour of wear.