Customer Reviews Cole Haan Sadie Open Toe Wedge 65mm

Beautiful shoe and a great price for Cole Haans but these were not comfortable in the toe area when I walked. The shoe cut into the top of my toes so sadly I am returning them.

These are great. I have then in non-patent also. The patent ones have absolutely zero give/stretch, even after several wears. I’ve found them tighter than other similar cole haan shoes across the toes. Consider adding 1/2 size.

Fit was perfect. I'm a 7.5 and it was true to size. I have wider feet and it worked perfectly so may not be great for narrow feet. Love the look but still need to break them in, the only part that is slightly uncomfortable is the peep toe area...it rubs on my toes but I'm hoping with more wear that will go away.

I bought these shoes as my work shoes and I like them so far. They are easy to wear and comfortable to walk in. However, I feel like the overall size and width are too big for me. I wear a size 6 - 6 1/2 us and have a somewhat narrow feet so maybe that's why but I tried on a size 6 and it was a bit tight so I got my usual size and added a small padding in the front just for the fit. They are more on the $$$ side being $180 but the shoes are in great quality so I will be keeping them.

I wanted to keep these shoes so badly. Unfortunately, they made my left toe hurt. Sadly needed to return. They are so beautiful and comfortable otherwise. The peep toe is the problem. I wish that Cole Haan would make these as closed toe shoes.

Great shoe but I only bought it since the Tali style is discontinued. That is my shoe of choice for work. Hoped The Sadie could replace but it’s a bit too high/fancy for me.

Beautiful shoes. Unfortunately the right one have the side of my heel a killer blister- too painful even to cushion it with a bandaid. Hopefully they will break in with the next wear!

Absolutely beautiful shoe!! Sorry had to return as peep toe opening was too small and hurt at big toe area. I noticed others had same problem.

Color is more white-pink than nude so sending back. Fit was good, though.

i was surprised by how tightly they fit when I first tried it on. Maybe it is the cushy-ness, but it made me think I would not be able to wear it for long periods of time. I will try to get 1/2 size up and see how it goes!

These were cute but not $200 cute. Returned.

Returning. In size 10.5, the peep toe opening on these shoes is so high and wide, it just looks like a mac truck can drive through the front of the shoe. Not flattering. Otherwise the shoe is pretty and comfy.

I wanted to like these shoes because they were sooooo comfortable. But ultimately, they look comfortable if you know what I mean; not really very attractive.

Cole Haan shoes fit great, but the "nude" patent was very pale. I was certain that I was originally sent the lighter shade "Brazilian Sand Leather" so I ordered the nude patent again, and still a very pale color. I'm returning both. Great shoes otherwise. A little tall for me also, I prefer the 40mm wedges.

I love the look of this shoe. I ordered it my usual size 6, but the toe area was too cramped. Sad...must send back.

I wanted these shoes to work. They are beautiful and look so nice on the foot. But the peep toe cut into my big toe on both feet.

I so needed these but they were too small for me. Very sad. Style is neutral and wedge would be super comfortable.

I was hoping the 5.5 medium would fit my feet but it was too small. I usually wear 5.5 wide. But it is true to size 5.5 medium width. Really pretty shoes.

Not true to size and now out of stock with size I need

Great shoe, very comfortable. I really like the wooden wedge. The problem is the nude color is very pink. Would be better labeled as light pink.

These shoes run small. I would recommend ordering a half size larger than your normal size. My toes stuck out of the peep toe in my normal size, and I didn't think they felt like they would be as comfortable as I wanted. So, I returned them. I feel like they made my foot look like a potato too.

In short, I tried two different sizes in these and ended up returning both. I wear a 5.5 or 6 in most shoes. I started with a 5.5 in these shoes, but my toes were popping out of the peep toes. So, I ordered a 6, and my toes did the same thing. I think it's the style of the shoes, because I only ever worn a 6.5 in a pair of Nike running shoes. In fact, I just had to order a size 5 in Earth shoes and could easily wear a 4.5 if they made that size. So, I don't know what is going on with the sizing of these shoes. I also don't think the style is that great. They make my foot look wide, and my foot is on the narrow side of medium/average. So again, I think the style is just a bit off in these. The color was Aura Orange Patent. It's an orange-ish red color, which would be fine if the shoes fit better.

Beautiful shoe but....the edge around the peep toe rub the top of my toe - it would have been painful after a day in them so had to return. beautiful shoe though.

I ultimately did not like the style of this shoe. I've always disliked the "fake wood" wedge, but I've been so desperate to find a wedge to replace my beautiful, entirely nude (no-fake-wood) Cole Haan wedges from years ago, that I thought maybe - just maybe - I'd like these when I put them on. Turns out I still do not care for this style. Also, although the heel height was listed and I wear heels almost every day to work, these really were ultimately too high for my purposes (i.e., wearing them to work). I so wish Cole Haan would make a more modest-sized wedge in a complete nude and I swear I'd buy up five pairs. Until then...the search continues...

Color was far lighter than the picture looked. Ran large.