Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Cahill

I love these shoes. I actually wrote a review for these on a pair I had to return two days ago because they were a half size too big! I just got the pair that are a half size smaller than I normally wear and they fit perfectly. Please take my advice and order a half size down!

I have been searching for a casual loafer that you can dress up for quite some time now. Also, considering I live in a city I was looking for a shoe that a) wouldn't destroy after some walking and b) comfort. This shoe hit the mark. It's great. It's comfortable for walking long distances. You can fold the heel down to look like a bit of a mule. I bought the camel color and it looks good with everything I wear. I wear them to work, dinner, walking, out with friends... it's a great fall transition shoe. Highly recommend.

Nice looking shoe, very soft. A little narrow through the toe area, but I could have dealt with it. The problem is the heel. It's like the thinnest piece of leather, with zero support. Nothing to hold the heel area up even. Just a little flap. There might as well not even be a heel area. And even if there was any support, which there isn't, it only covers up about 2/3 of your heel. You just step right out of it. I really wanted to like this shoe, but I just cannot keep it.

Love this shoe! Have it in navy and wear it all the time, so just ordered the camel as well. Leather is extremely soft and comfortable, and you can dress it up for work or down with jeans. Not a lot of structure/support, but extremely comfortable. One note -- the camel color (maple sugar) is not a traditional beige or camel. It's a warmer color (almost but not quite a rose tint to it).

Bought these in 3 colors and loved them EXCEPT that after a few wears, since they have NO back support, the back of the shoe has started to collapse. I don't know what they will be like in a few months so that's a concern. Also, they don't run consistent in size. I bought all 3 in size 9 but had to return the Blue for an 8.5.

I love the look and feel of these shoes. They would not be great for long periods of walking but they are comfortable overall. They look fantastic with jeans or leggings.

These were really cute and I wish I could have kept them. I don't have a very wide foot, but I can't usually wear super-narrow shoes. That wouldn't have been a problem with these if I could have worn them as-is after the leather stretched a bit. The issue with these is that they have no arch support, and as I'm recovering from Plantar Fasciitis I need some extra support. Adding my insoles made these impossible to get onto my foot. LSS: These are a bit narrower than normal and have no arch support. If you have narrow or normal feet and don't need insoles, these should fit fine.

I have an WW wide foot. I thought this shoe looked boxy enough to handle my wider foot. it did not. I could not get into a size wide shoe. Otherwise quite stylish

I loved the look, but couldn’t get them to stay on. Bummed, but I read the reviews and I should have listened. The heel completely falls flat. I’d like to try a half size smaller, but they’re sold out.

Super cute and soft. Seems like it will be comfortable however ordered a half size smaller based on reviews and shouldn’t have. Also seems to run narrow so returning and ordering my size in a wide width. Fingers crossed it will fit

Loved the look and feel of these shoes but they have no arch support. They ran a half size small, which I would have ordered up if they had arch support.

I really wanted to love these. The style is outstanding, the leather is buttery soft, and the color is beautiful, but the left one won't stay on my heel, which is really odd because that foot is slightly larger than my right foot. There's just no structural integrity to the back of the shoe. Finally had to give up on them and send back.

Bizarre shoe, there’s no structure in the heel, it’s like a loose piece of fabric and it feels SO cheap!

I wear a wide shoe, when these arrived they were clearly a medium. I couldn’t get my foot in the shoe.

As always Zappos is an awesome company to order from and returns are so simple and easy, thank you Zappos. Liked the way the shoes looked, wanted to like them, but they were not comfortable, fit snug across the toes even though they were wide width, the fold down felt way thinner then the rest of the shoe, with the fold down up it kept slipping down and off my feet when I tried to walk, they had a rubbery spot on the ball of the outer foot so that part of the shoe didn't slip, but the heels were made of plastic ? and they slipped around while trying to walk. Didn't feel safe to walk across the room let alone wear on a regular basis, alas had to return...