Customer Reviews Naturalizer Marianne

I love the style of these shoes and ordered these exact shoes in a different color a week ago. Unfortunately this black pair didn’t fit at all. It was like someone wore them for a few days that needed 2 sizes larger and stretched them out. I sent them them back..

I have a pair of Dr. Scholl's Madison that look like these that I love, so I thought they would fit the same. It rubs on the sides of the toe box, so I decided to return. Any deciding between the two based on width, Dr. Scholl's Madison is more true to width.

It's difficult finding attractive shoes in narrow. These shoes looked cute, but were overall too wide for my narrow feet. There was a gap that appeared on the side of the shoe whenever I walked. I usually wear an 8.5 narrow in tennis shoes, so I bought 8N and the length was fine. There didn't seem to be any arch support.

Correct size but was wide thru the heel.

I’m pretty happy with these shoes, but there are definitely some major drawbacks. My foot measures 7.5EEE, and I have a high instep- it’s close to impossible to find a stylish shoe in my size! I bought these in the pink suede in size 8WW. They are wide enough (just barely- especially since I went up half size for width), but they are comfortable. The insole is padded and they are nice to walk and stand around in. If I’m sitting for any length of time though, the top of the shoe starts cutting into the top of my foot and I need to take them off. I haven’t had issues with stains yet- I’ve been very careful, but I have noticed the fabric separating from the rubber around the sides. Not the quality I would expect from Naturalizer, but that’s a trade off I unfortunately have to make.

I was looking for a simple pair of slip-on shoes to wear while working in the yard or garden. They didn't have to be fashionable, just comfortable and reasonably durable. These certainly fit that description, and as I wear a 9.5 AA, I've learned to live with limited options that do meet my needs. Having said that, the Mauve Nubuck--the only color available in my size--is, in my opinion, UGLY. I don't know what color I'd call it, but it's not my idea of mauve. I'm just reminding myself that no color is pretty once I get it good and dirty!

Oh how I wanted to this shoe to fit, but the spot where the elastic attaches to the shoe on the side is too narrow and pinches. It's so hard to find cute shoes in wide widths. Disappointed!

Not enough cushion, already falling apart.

Received a pair of returned shoes. Left shoe had creases in leather from previous wear. Scuffs were present on white sides and a piece of dog hair was stuck to one of the shoes. I love the style of the shoes and needed some for a new job I start in a few days so no time to exchange/return. Disappointed in the quality control especially for almost $60 shoes

This shoe came further up on the top of my foot than I expected. Didn't like the way it looked on.

I wear a 10 narrow and these gaped a lot. Sad to have to return them but they did not fit. Wish someone would make a truly narrow shoe.

Wish these had worked for me. Narrow heel with bunion on left foot and wide forefoot. Unfortunately flopped off my heel even with socks.

I was disappointed that they were so sloppy. I’m returning them. I had another pair in a different color from last year that WERE narrow enough, and I was hoping to have the same fit! So I’m bummed!

Too bad this narrow wasn't actually narrow. I liked the style though, and the quality. It was just waaaayy wide.

I love the style but after only 5 months of occasional wear these are really faded and worn. Cute but maybe not best quality...

Shoe sizing runs large, I'd recommend going down a size. Style and comfort are decent for quick slip on to run errands or chase kids, and they make it through a day at the office, too. Disappointed in the quality, after wearing them a handful of times the seam around the toe box is already pulling away from leather, leaving a visible gap when walking or bent.

I ordered these in a 10N. They were not narrow at all. I even wonder if they were mismarked. I tried on a pair of 10B at a department store just to see the difference and even they were not as wide as the 10N was. I like the style and they have a nice soft insole but just too wide.

Since I purchased these same shoes in a different color and love the fit so I thought I'd order a pair in black. Unfortunately the black ones felt wider and my heel just slipped when walking. Disappointed that I have to return these.

The width on these is NOT WW. I typically wear a W, and these were too narrow :(

The style and appearance of this shoe was exactly what I wanted. Unfortunately, it didn't fit - felt as if it was a half size smaller.

These shoes were not as comfortable as I expected for a Naturalizer shoe. Quite narrow and the heel is tight, causing friction. I had to take them off after an hour on day one, so they won't be coming to Europe with me :( Will try wearing again, indoors, but these may be going back.

These shoes have good cushioning in the sole, more comfortable than any other shoe I have purchased. I ordered a 4.5 and it's really hard to find shoes that are attractive and not meant for little kids or old people. Vans has a similar one but not for kids. I ordered the medium width though, which is way too tight. I couldn't purchase the wide width because the smallest size was a 6. I couldn't size up to a 5 because it would be too long and hard to walk in. In the past when I have sized up to a 5 the back heel gets taller and rubs, giving me blisters. The length also slides around if its longer, which means more blisters in the toe box area. I have wide feet but these are the thinnest sneakers I have tried on. I ordered a shoe stretcher which has helped a lot, but after stretching for 16 hours I still got blisters. I bought these for walking/comfort so its frustrating to wear three band aids on one foot. Two were for the toe box, and one was for the back heel. It was so tight in the toe box that it pushed my foot back, rubbing against the heel. Overall the quality is good but I feel these are made for kids with thinner feet, not petite women.