Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

Love this shoe! So thankful it comes in size 10.5, not many do. I wore it for a wedding, 9 hours total with no previous break-in. It was comfy all night! “Soft Nude Pearl Leather” is a beautiful nude with a hint of pink and a pearl finish, very pretty! Will definitely purchase in additional colors.

These are great shoes. Very stylish, yet comfortable. (also they don't take up much space....I walk to work in sneakers and change when I get to work). I loved my black ones so much that I bought two more colors; unfortunately, they seemed to fit a b it too tightly so I returned those

I love these shoes! I have a narrow foot with a high arch and bought the 8 narrow, my usual size. The shoe rubbed my heel a bit on the first day but days two and subsequent have been wonderful - that's all it took to break them in. I usually avoid pointed toe shoes but fell for the D'Orsay style, and have to say these are pretty comfy and look refined in a way my traditional almond toe does not. These are nice looking substitutes for heels and look good with a pencil skirt or slacks. I recommend and expect to buy in other colors.

LOVE these shoes! They took a few wears to break in, but now they're my go to pair for work. They fit my wide foot really well.

Very cute flats for every day or office. Cute style, comfortable from the start for me.

I cannot believe how comfortable these flats. Wore them all day at work with no sore feet and no problems. Have to wear a wide shoe. These were perfect-no pinching...nothing! Wish they were in other colors!

Slim, sleek, and stylish. Comfortable but hurt a bit after 9hr of work day. Maybe meant for a few hours of wear.

Tight across the top of each foot. Maybe I needed a wider shoe, not sure. Otherwise the fit was good.

I REALLY wanted to like these shoes!! The color is awesomely unique. I wish/hope they come up with others styles in this color. This particular shoe would NOT stay on my feet. Every other step my foot popped out. Ultimately I need to be able to walk more than 5 steps so these are being returned. But the color!!! PLEASE Naturalizer - make more shoes in this chocolate pearl. It is literally one of my favorite brown shoes!

I ordered the Lodge Brown Pearl Leather color and it was a very nice copper mid-tone. The leather is nice and supple and feels very good quality. The sheen is subtle but the color still acts as a neutral so they go with a lot of different things. I wore these inside a bit in hopes to break them in but my first day wearing them to work they did give me massive blisters on the sides of my heels under and slightly back of my ankle bone. The back heel cup is very narrow and I wish I'd spent more time trying to "round" the heel cup before I wore them so it wouldn't rub the side of the back of my foot. I have a tennis ball rubber-banded in the heel cup now to try to better shape it more like an actual heel (who has heels like triangles that come to a point at the back?) and I'm hoping that will do the trick. Another thing to note is that the toe of the shoe comes up on your foot more than other flats. If you are used to seeing the tip of your toe creases, you won't see those here. The part of the toe that comes across the foot is pretty straight it doesn't scoop towards your toes. The footbed has a lot of cushion, especially at the ball of the foot, and the point was pretty long so there was plenty of room for my toes. It is on the longer side of pointy toes so I did feel like I had to lift my feet a little bit more so I didn't trip over the toe. I am probably going to give them one more chance - I do have a few pairs of favorite shoes that gave me blisters at first and then broke in with no issues, so I am hoping that is the case with these.

I love Zappos and love this style but it was not wide enough for my very wide feet. I will return these shoes.

I don't recommend this shoe if you wear wide sizes. The shoe pinches in a strange way that makes the otherwise attractive shoe look bad.

Really cute, my feet disagree. I ordered another shoe with a similar cut and a pair of ballet-style flats in the same order. These were noticeably narrower than the other two. They’re really nice construction, good padding for this type of shoe, and have a little wedge of elastic at the edge of the vamp. I’d think about stretching these, but it’s a D’orsay, so I have to wear them with bare feet unless I’m wearing tights, which ruins the point of choosing a D’orsay to begin with. My feet will raise blisters if I even think about going without at least footies, so these will delight someone, but not me. That’s the fault of my feet, not the shoe. I’d have given more stars except that the sizing seems off n comparison to the two other brands I ordered at the same time.

These stretch out as you wear them, just a little to big and slip off while wearing! I’m usually a 8.5-9 and the 8.5 was too big. Disappointed because they are comfortable and adorable.

Cute flats -- unfortunately, have to return. My feet are on the narrower side and my feet kept slipping out of the shoe when I took a step. The length was true to size, but the shoes were too wide for me.

I'm in between a size 5 and 5.5 depending on the shoe. I previously ordered a size 5 from the Naturalizer website in silver, and they were too big. I ordered a 4.5 in yellow from Zappos and found it to be a perfect fit. I'm returning them for two reasons, though: 1) the yellow is so much paler than in the photos (this is also true for the red "hot sauce" pair) and 2) the soles of the the shoes I received from Zappos are very slippery compared to the rubber soles on the pair I bought from the Naturalizer website. I'm not sure if different colorways have different soles but I much prefer the rubber soles to the smooth slippery ones. Overall, it is a cute and comfortable shoe. I'd suggest ordering a half-size smaller, though.

These fit as expected and were a cute style, but the leather is really stiff. Even though they fit properly, I could tell the leather would destroy my feet. I ordered these in the nude pearl leather, which wound up being shinier than I prefer. Ultimately, I think cheaper shoes of the same quality are available, so I returned these.

love these shoes, but after the first time wearing them they expanded and now hard to keep on feet.

This shoe was so narrow!!! I ordered a wide, and I felt like Cinderella's stepsisters ... I couldn't even get my foot inside of it. A 7 wide usually fits me, but not this one. Otherwise, a beautiful shoe.

These were incredibly small and narrow. That combined with a hard inflexible lining made them very uncomfortable. Very unlike naturalizer’s normal fit. As far as appearance, they fall somewhere between stylish flat and 1940s housewife bedroom slipper.

I’m a always size 8 and usually wide. These however felt a little long and not quite wide enough. I really wanted them to work but I know the left shoe just sat wrong and won’t have lasted a day of work.

Very narrow. Go 1/2 side up. No arch support. Stylish and cute shoe though.

I'm so bummed out because I was so excited to get these. They are not wide enough for my wide feet + large bunions. Had to return them.

These are a soft leather. My recommended size from Zappos is 7M, but I buy a 7.5N when I can find them. I ordered these in a 7.5M because I needed a longer toe box due to the point, and they don't come in a N width. After stretching them out, the length is comfortable, but I have to put a grip on the heel so they don't slip right off. As another reviewer noted, they wrinkle where your toe bends. It doesn't hurt, but it doesn't look great either. I bought them because I needed a smooth sole for dance class, and these work. I don't expect them to (sadly) last very long. Definitely not a walking shoe, no support and a thin sole. This is desperation buying.

I had been admiring these shoes for a while. Finally ordered them and will be immediately returning. Wow they are uncomfortable! Surprisingly stiff and pinched my feet at the toe, heel, and across the top. I realize they would likely soften since they are leather, I'm just not willing to go through the pain.