Customer Reviews TOMS Stella Wedge

Cute shoe, wanted to love it, but just not as comfortable as expected.

I wish this shoe and TOMS in general came in Wide!! I love the look of this shoe. Unfortunately, I need wide and wearing this shoe in medium absolutely kills my little toe. If you are a true medium, get this shoe. If your foot is wider, don't force it -- pass on this shoe -- the pain and possible bunion is not worth it despite how cute the shoe is.

Too tight. I have very small feet and these squished the toe box too much.

Run really small

Great looking shoe. I ordered a 1/2 size up after reading the reviews. The length fit, but it was too wide. I do not have a narrow foot either. Wanted to

Runs right. I had to return and get a smaller size as I ordered up. Really pretty but not comfortable.

I really like the look of these shoes but they run a bit narrow and the edges are so sharp! They cut right into the sides of my feet :(

These are very cute but they are so stiff I didn't even want to try to break them in. It almost feels like there's a shellac or other treatment on the fabric to make them hold their shape, but it just made it rock hard. Very pretty in person though, so maybe it was just my feet.

These are adorable, but too small. I read the reviews and ordered a half size up and they were still too small.

Super cute and I was so excited to receive these in the gray, which was purchased to match a new Italian gray leather handbag. Color was perfect! Size was too small. I ordered a 7.5 and am truly a 7.5. Reordering an 8 now. Followup to come.

I bought different Toms wedges last year that were the most comfortable wedges ever. So I bought these in the exact same size and I was definitely disappointed. They are much narrower at the heel and they feel a bit smaller. They are also not comfortable at all. HOWEVER, I am keeping them because they are the cutest shoes and match my dress.

I bought these because I have a pair of Tom's canvas wedges I bought a few years ago and LOVE them. These are not the same. The heel is higher and less comfortable. I do like the more delicate toe box detailing, but with the higher heel it just is not comfortable. My old pair were my go-to shoes for comfort, but sadly, I'm returning these. Love the new color choices, just wish they'd left the old heel height.

These are so cute but sadly I'll return. There is not much comfort and the toe area is a little painful. The size was right but my foot constantly slipped out the back. For the price, not worth keeping.

Oh how I wanted to love these! These shoes checked off everything on my list: neutral, wedge, pep toe, summery, and not too high. They are soooo cute but they KILLED my toes. I just wore them in the house to try them on and you could see my toes starting to turn purple, they were so tight in the toe box. I don't have particularly large toes or wide feet. The size was right, I'm normally a 6.5 and these fit perfect otherwise. There was also nothing comfort wise under the toes and after wearing them for 5 minutes, my feet hurt for the rest of the night. Super disappointing since these were perfect for my outfit!

These shoes are so cute, but they are SUPER tiny and narrow! I almost always wear a 6.5, and ordered that same size here. I honestly couldn't even get my foot into it. Honestly, I think I would need a full size larger than normal to fit length, and even then, I doubt it would be wide enough.

I love the look of these shoes, but they killed my feet. The tor opening is too small and made my toes go numb.

Cute shoe but the denim stretched out a ton after 1 wear. I should have returned them but wore them and felt bad. Haven’t worn since

Not great

They ran big on me and were less comfortable than I hoped. I returned. They are cute for summer but definitely size down.

I wore these for the first time and they absolutely destroyed my feet. I had so many blisters on both feet by the end of the day, that it took two weeks for my feet to fully heal. They are very cute and I wanted so badly for them to work, but I can't bring myself to put them on again after that experience.

I love the look of this shoe. I'd buy all colors if they'd fit true to size.

They look great. Unfortunately, they kill my feet. Tom's should never have used this fabric. I have the same style in a different lighter fabric with no issues but these are so painful. The fabric is extremely stiff and creates blisters all over my toes and sides of my feet. I went out and bought moleskin thinking that would solve the issue. But even lining the interior with moleskin did not help, just made them tighter. Ordering the next size up results in the shoe feeling too loose and falling off. The size advertised is the size that should fit. Basically these are defective shoes because you really can't walk in them for more than a few minutes without pain/blisters. Money wasted.

I had the first generation of Toms wedges and they were much more comfortable. The material in these is so stiff, and there's a lot of pressure and not a lot of support in the ball of the foot. No match for the original wedges - these are sexier looking, and I can usually take one for the team in the comfort category for that - but this is just too much. Going back.

These are extremely adorable and lightweight. The problem is that the toe box is very narrow. Depending on the shoe I either need a B or C width. I wish these had an option other than the normal width because I would have kept them. There is also little to no give in the fabric so they wouldn't have stretched.