Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Shelby

These shoes looks and feels luxurious. Heel is just a skosh high but manageable. Does run tighter/smaller than expected may return for 1/2 up when available.

I love Sam Edelman and these shoes did not disappoint! I'd purchased them to replace a more uncomfortable pair of Aldo shoes and so far they've been very comfortable! The heel is very reasonable but still appears to be high and the suede is great quality.

I wear these constantly. I needed a cute, versatile black ankle bootie that didn't break the bank and these nail it.

I love these booties! I bought them because I already had a pair of flat Sam Edelman leather booties and like those, these did not disappoint! They are a bit narrow on the toe (I have wide feet), but my feet do not slide down into the toes or pinch. The heel height is perfect and I could wear them all day without my feet hurting!

Beautiful boots! Fit true to size. Quality construction. Look great with pants or skirts. My feet hurt a little by the end of a work day, but don't they always in heels? Overall a great buy!

Love the style, and so comfortable!

This is exactly what I was looking for in a bootie and they did not disappoint. Wearing them again tonight!

Beautiful booties, great for a casual look with jeans or you can easily dress them up with a skirt.

I wear these shoes under slacks for work and often walk around a mile in them during my lunch break. For such a high heel they are extremely comfy, and the soft rubber on the soles make it quiet and add extra comfort to your step. True to size.

Love these! They did hurt the first 3 wears, then once broken in, they feel great!!

Exactly what I wanted. These look great with a dress and are comfortable for standing long periods of time.

This is my fourth pair of Sam Edelman shoes, so it's safe to say I'm a little obsessed. Their shoes are always true to size, comfortable, and stylish and these are no exception.

These are so SOFT! The heel height is manageable, and they look cute! They have a nice grippy bottom so no need to worry about slipping or loud boots clomping around.

Beautuful! The side cuts make these boots great with jeans or dresses.

Fabulous looking bootie great for pants, skirts and dresses...AND comfy

Love these boots. I'm usually a size 8.5 but the size 8 was perfect for me. The black suede boots looked super cute paired with a sweater dress for a dinner with my husband. I have wide feet and usually prefer flats or small heels but these were very comfortable and easy to walk in.

The leather on this school felt so soft. I returned the shoe because it was too tight. I recommend getting a size larger if you don't have narrow feet.

A little too tight for me near the toe The inside is also a little slippery so can make your foot slide down towards the toe when wearing socks

I found this boot to be extremely tight at the widest part of the boot. The leather is soft and might give some but I don't want it to look stretched out. No other widths available so I guess back to the drawing board...

These boots are very pretty but unfortunately I could NOT make them work for me! I tried the 8 which felt like the right length but WAY too narrow (like freakishly tight and narrow), and the 8.5 which felt both too long and too wide. The heel is a little high for an all-day wear but if these fit your feet, I think they'd be comfortable. FYI my feet are slightly on the wider side of regular with low-medium arches. The boots were super soft and beautiful in person, but for some reason they were shipping from the Amazon store versus the regular. I'm not sure what difference this makes, but both pairs I received were clearly returned from other people, as they were packed with mismatched paper/cardboard inserts and were also a bit scuffed or dirty. Quality wise, I might not have kept them even if they fit. For the price, I'd hope they would show up pristine.

very cute styling...but ran very narrow and small. I have too wide of feet and need to send back.