Customer Reviews Naturalizer Zarie

Sharp looking bootie, beautiful leather. Sizing was the problem - I ordered a half size up to accommodate sox and keep toes from being squeezed, but my heel slipped when I walked. Other reviewers said the same but I had to find out for myself.

For a narrow boot this is more like a medium width. Too wide for me - the boot is falling off my foot. Note: I don't have a super narrow foot and in the past Naturalizer shoes in a narrow size have always fit me.

I really wanted to like this boot it would have been four stars which is pretty good in my book if not for the weird sizing of the boots. First off I feel they do run narrow. Secondly the right shoe was huge almost like a full size larger than my left shoe even though they're both marked the same size! The left shoe fits me perfectly even though I ordered a width larger than usual - while my right foot was swimming in the right shoe. Lining up the souls together I can definitely see that the right shoe is made larger overall. The footprint is slightly bigger which is easy to tell by lining them up and the overall foot volume not only feels bigger but looks bigger on my foot as well. This sort of quality inconsistency is an acceptable at this price point so they're going back. If the sizing was consistent they would have been great with their super comfortable foot bed.

These booties are the style I am looking for, but they run small. I have a thick instep and boots are very hard to fit. Have to keep looking!

I really wish this boot fit, but I ordered in wide and it feels like a narrow! Zappos is out of stock in WW. I may try to go to the Naturalizer site and order a half size up in WW, but that is ridiculous when I usually wear M or a W in my normal size. It feels like it would be comfortable if not so narrow.

Returning the usual 9M I always order and am going to try a 9C (Wide). I've never had to order a "C" before - so believe the reviewers that say IT RUNS NARROW. Nice looking boot, with quality materials. It does not come up as high as some other booties, but I like that. If you don't want a bootie that sits low on the foot, this is not for you. I'm hoping the wide size fits well, as I love the style and color (it can be hard to find a true saddle brown).

Love the style of these boots, but the 10W is too snug! I hope they make these in WW so that I can buy these!

These are very comfortable which is now my #1 criteria for shoes being a woman in my 40s. I've worn them walking to my train every day (about 10 minutes each way) and around town on the weekend. I've had a little rub on the heel but nothing major. They are also super cute. I got the grey and I really like the color. I think they will look nice with a skirt and tights as well as jeans.

I ordered 1/2 size up, which it seems is pretty standard for me in boots and booties. They were decently comfortable but I am sending them back because I can't get passed the pirate shoe styling. Not the sexy boot I was looking for. Just straight up pirate. Arrgh!

These shoes are beautiful! I ordered a 7.5 which is what I usually wear, but these were too small. Hope to order an 8 when this shoe is back in stock!

I love booties and this is by far my favorite! Great quality. I wear it everyday. As a teacher, there is definitely a lot of walking (at various pace at times!). This pair of shoes certainly does the job. I highly recommend.

They were cute and comfortable, but I fall between sizes and they felt a little small.

I usually wear a 10 or 10.5 and these shoes and ordered a 10.5. They were VERY tight! Especially in the heel. I would size up! They are super-cute shoes, though!

The brown pair was narrow and too tight around my toes. I ordered black pair too and it felt wider and perfect.

NOT WIDE! At all! Ordered a WW, felt and looked like a normal width. Bizarre.