Customer Reviews Sofft Selby

I have extremely high arches and thick ankles, making for challenges when buying booties. These booties were slightly tough to get my feet into, but once they were on they were fabulous! I wore a light sock with them and my feet were very comfortable. No break in period needed, good arch support, light on the feet and nice looking.I highly recommend the Selby and will most likely buy another pair Ina different color!

I love these boots! They were comfortable from the moment I slipped them onto my feet! The jodphur style elastic makes getting them on & off super easy- I despise the redundancies of many boots these days (zippers on boots that already have laces, etc.) so I was happy to find these b/c of that. Also, I have moderate bunions on each foot with a narrow heel and these boots accommodated them perfectly! My feet do not slide around. I wear these to work where I am standing for up to 6 hours at a time and my feet don't hurt at all. The style and color of the red aristo is a little less red than in the pic, more like a mahogany, but I like this- it goes with anything. These boots look great with skinny or boot cut jeans and skirts too. Well worth the investment of $170.

My toe area is wide while my heel is narrow, so I was a little worried about sizing on this. I am a size 8 in sneakers and boots and went for a size 8 - it fits well!! The toe area is snug with winter socks, just right. My foot does not fall out while walking nor does it jiggle around much. They look smart, are so easy to pull on and off quickly, and look great with jeans or leggings. The inside is extremely comfy with great squish to it. I have flat feet and the arch support is comfortable - many shoes tend to make my flat feet ache if they have a high arch support. I don’t know how they found that balance here but it’s magic. Super happy with this!

Super comfortable boot, but please note that it looks lighter in person (see photo below). II purchased the Selby in Whiskey (top) and Bergamo (bottom) in Whiskey and the Bergamo was much darker. Ended up returning these because I prefer the darker shade but if you don't mind that, this is a stylish, comfortable boot.

Super comfortable highly recommend.

I love these boots. I took an 8.5 when I normally need a size 9 in boots. They are comfortable right out of the box.

I normally take a 7.5W, but decided to try these in a size 8M. The width and length actually felt pretty good and the footbed was comfortable right out of the box. Despite the lack of a zipper, it was fairly easy to get the boot on and off. The thing that was uncomfortable for me, though was the shaft. The leather felt very stiff and just walking around my living room the top of the boot was really irritating on my shin. This might improve over time, but I wasn't willing to take a chance.

Discovered this brand while looking for an inexpensive, low-heel boot to wear during a summer of city-walking. For the price, this is a well-made boot, without the super-pointy western toe that is so popular, but stylistically limiting. Wish the there was a tad more padding in the foot-bed (probably curable with inserts) and wish the heel was a smidgen higher. One genuine con: I did find the sizes differed between colors (saddle was bigger than black and a slightly stiffer leather). Great boot for the price.

Comfortable, well made booties. I really like the tapering around the heel. They are easy to take on and off, and the squishy footbed is great. The height is such that you can wear short socks without any problems. My only complaint would be that, because of my very thin ankles, they look a little clown-ish on me.

WOW! These are the PERFECT boots!!! I am a 9.5 with high arches, and my design job requires walking over 5mi. every day across concrete floorS while presenting an aesthetically-minded appearance. These boots are utterly divine. Their silhouette and construction is perfect, they keep their shape without appearing too stiff, are extremely lightweight, have great arch support, have a padded foot bed, and are the perfect whiskey color with a slightly-almond round-toe. UTTER PERFECTION! BUYING IN BLACK!

I've had these shoes for a few months now, and I couldn't be happier with them. They've weathered San Francisco's rainy hills, Chicago's icy streets, and Atlanta's hot pavement, and they've felt great the entire time. I'd buy them again in a heartbeat.

I am so happy with these boots I had to come write a review. Found my just-right chelsea boot, after I ordered and returned 4 others. Some were cute but uncomfortable; others were comfortable but didn't look quite right to me. These are so comfortable I can't stop wearing them, and they look great, too.

I ordered the red ones. They look great and are comfortable as can be. The only drawback is they should have a pull up tab to help get them on.

So happy I got these boots! I have been looking for a pair of Chelsea boots and was worried these wouldn’t be quite the right color. After reading the reviews and seeing that the color was lighter than shown in the pictures, I went ahead got them and LOVE the color. They also make my ankles look skinny (always a plus). They are also very comfortable and will be able to be worn with a variety of outfits. Highly recommend!

I am in love! These boots went on the minute they have arrived and they are pretty much the only thing I wear now! They felt like I have had them for ages, broken in perfectly and sooooo comfortable.

color not accurate. These are much lighter in person.

I love love love these shoes! I wore them all day with comfort!. In fact I was so impressed I ordered Sofft boots but unfortunately my calves are too large. Zappos is wonderful!

Super comfy and cute, but this Whiskey color is very light IMO. The website picture looks darker to me. Also, compared to other boots, these feel roomier - which is a good thing. But keep it in mind when ordering size.

This is my second pair, so comfortable when you are on your feet all day. My only complaint it that the little tab on the rear of the bootie, which logically you'd use to pull the booties on, is not strong and will break, loosing the rivet. Great value, I may buy more for future use.

So comfortable and practical, but also cute!

These boots are extremely comfortable with good arch support. I really wanted them to work, but the toe area is quite round/wide and makes my feet look larger than they already are (I am 5'3" and size 9.5), so unfortunately I will be returning them.

I love these boots! Easy to get on and off, stylish and also rugged/durable. Very comfortable after initial discomfort where the top of the boot would run against my upper ankle. It’s not at all an issue now though!

These felt broken in right out of the box.

These are my go-to boots for everyday. They are so comfortable I normally choose them over sneakers. They are really cute and have held up really well this first year of wear. I just ordered another pair in brown!