Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Giorgie

Fine looking and nice quality, but shockingly narrow.

I had purchased the Greige woven version of this shoe in my normal size 7 and loved it so I went back and ordered the black and the whiskey. When they arrived, they felt amazingly small compared to my first pair. Too narrow and too tight around the toes. I think it might partially be because of the change in material but I unfortunately had to return them.

These shoes felt more narrow than marked. The soles of the shoes were comfortable, but I can't wear these with a bunion. The top/front of the shoe extended further than my toes, and the width didn't accommodate my bunions. Unlike some other reviews I saw, the top of the shoe fully covered my toes, leaving no toe "cleavage" that my feet needed to fit.

I wore them for a day and had blisters on my heels by the end of the day because they were too large.

I ordered this exact shoe a year ago and had to go one half size down. I ordered them again (trying to think ahead since I LOVE the pair I have and don't want to have to shop around for a new leopard flat whenever these totally wear out) and the shoe interior has changed. Now, on either side of the interior heel, there are little "bumps" of a supportive fabric (I guess to increase comfort?) and the shoe sizing has definitely changed. Last year I had to return the 8 for a 7.5; this time I returned the 7.5 and will need to order an 8. I'm really hopeful that the 8 fits well, and I'm disappointed the shoe design has changed because the previous design was great.

I should have paid more attention to those reviews written by those with larger feet! I too am a size 11 and found that the toe box pinches my pinkie toes slightly.

too big

Bunions make shoes a challenge, I get it, but these didn't solve any of my problems. Too short, too narrow (even in what they mark as wide). I know I shouldn't get my hopes up on finding flats that don't kill my feet, but it's still disappointing.

Weird fit. Pinched my heel & a bit snug all over. If these were leather they would break in nicely, but they look synthetic. I used a shoe stretcher in them for over a week & it didn't help.

I should have listened to the other reviewer who is also a size 11. I am somewhere between 11 and 11W, so I ordered both. The W was waaay too wide (but narrow in the toe box) and the 11 fit but hurt my toes immediately. Both of them are going back. It's a shame too, since these shoes were cute, but the fit is too wildly off and they are unwearable.

These were both too small length-wise and not anywhere near wide enough. Plus the fabric on one of the shoes was already fraying and I would have returned them even if they’d fit

The size was true but the top seam across the toes is super tight.

I have other pairs of this brand's memory foam insole shoes in other styles, and had high hopes for this one as well. I tried the black leather and leopard, and unfortunately the space in the toe box was too tight and very uncomfortable. It wasn't even that the shoes weren't wide enough there, but the actual height of the shoe was too small; it squeezed the top of my foot. Back they go.

Gorgeous shoe! Wish they had been comfortable. Maybe it was a size thing.

I initially ordered a size 11 based on the reviews. (I wear 10/10.5/11 depending on make and style.) 11 was too big, with my heel sliding out as I walked. Exchanged that pair for a 10, which fit...BUT I assume that 10.5 would have been perfect for me. Unfortunately, Dr. Scholl's doesn't make a 10.5 in this shoe :( My left shoe has a slight gape alongside the arch that I am still determining whether or not is a dealbreaker with this shoe. There is also minimal toe cleavage which I don't love, but can tolerate. I'm sad that this shoe isn't a slam dunk. The leopard pony hair upper is cute and the shoe is easily dressed up or down. The heel is padded as an attempt to mitigate rubbing and blisters, but I did notice some sensitivity in that area after the first few wears.

These were a little more pointed than I expected. They felt wide in the middle of the shoe when they were bent making them feel too wide and too big and I don't have narrow feet.

Could have been comfortable but felt a little too short or maybe too shallow at the toe. I did not exchange for a bigger size because they do not make 10 1/2 and I decided that I prefer more of a rounded toe than these have.

I initially really liked this shoe. It was comfortable and there was nice support and padding for a flat. I also liked the nude color - it wasn't too peachy or pink. However, the more I walked in them, the more I noticed the sides gaped and the width was just too wide.

I ordered these in a size 10, Medium width. The toe box of this shoe was too narrow; I think the toe box is not really built for the toes of people with larger feet. They are very cute, but they had to be returned.

I tried an 8, my normal size, too big. These 7.5 are still too big - maybe too wide. Not much arch support; they aren't going to work for me.