Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Giorgie

Rated 2 stars only because they are true to size. My heals stick to the insoles & they make noise every time I walk. I have to dust them with powder to keep it from happening... This doesn't happen with any other of my dress shoes that I wear daily. Not ideal for a quiet office! They are cheaply made and a disappointment since I held Dr Scholl's to a higher standard. They also rub my toes and heals, even though the sizing is correct. These shoes were a big waste of money.

They look as promised, but they carved a massive blister into my heal within 10 minutes, even though they are the exact same shoe and size as the black pair that I wore all weekend.

These shoes are incredibly cute and are also so so painful. Bought seeking flats that didn't hurt my feet, which was true, but my heels were bleeding after minutes during a test walk. Still have bandaids on 4 days later.

The shoes look classic, and they have good support. The heal and rim of the toe box digs into your feet so badly. I want to like them, but I'm having difficulty!

These are actually pretty uncomfortable shoes. The sole is fine, but the edges pinch into my outer foot and the heel is rough as well. I was hopeful about these but I was disappointed.

They are a cute shoe. I really like the soft matte material on the outside. They were very tight around the top of my foot where my toes went into the shoe, and the heel was very uncomfortable. They also bowed out and creased really bad where my foot bent at the balls of my feet. I couldn't even make them one full day. Had them off most of the day at my desk. Even while sitting it was uncomfortable. As far as the size that was correct and they fit well. I do have kind of fat feet so maybe they are just made for slim feet. Who knows. Just not for me.

These are true to size, cute, the insoles are nice BUT the back tears up above my heel where the top of the back of the shoe meets my skin. Even wearing peds and ensuring they're pulled up in the back, it rubs right through. I bought these to replace very similar looking ones that cause my arches to ache if I have to walk a lot at work. I'm back to wearing those because they at least don't draw blood. I thought maybe they just needed to be broken in, but after about 10 full day wears, no improvement. Super disappointed. I ordered some of those heel inserts, hopefully once I get them it will make these wearable. I've had uncomfortable shoes many times, but I didn't expect that from this particular brand.

Not comfortable at all. They run a little big and they do not fit my foot correctly. These are some of the most uncomfortable flats I have ever worn. The only nice thing about them in the "memory foam." The actual structure of the shoe is not good.

They were cute but super uncomfortable. Returned them.

I bought 2 pairs of these, whiskey and black. The black ones are a little wide, but other than that they are great. The whiskey ones, on the other hand, are absolutely awful. They have 2 squishy bubbles on the back that I am guessing are supposed to prevent blisters. However, they are extremely uncomfortable. I could feel them pushing into my feet all day and they actually ended up causing blisters which is pretty ironic. I'm not sure why the whiskey ones have these bumps and the black ones don't even though they're the same style? I never would have bought them if I knew that was a feature. I am very disappointed.

I bought 2 pairs of these, whiskey and black. The black ones are a little wide, but other than that they are great. The whiskey ones, on the other hand, are absolutely awful. They have 2 squishy bubbles on the back that I am guessing are supposed to prevent blisters. However, they are extremely uncomfortable. I could feel them pushing into my feet all day and they actually ended up causing blisters which is pretty ironic. I'm not sure why the whiskey ones have these bumps and the black ones don't even though they're the same style? I never would have bought them if I knew that was a feature. I am very disappointed.

I love a good ballet flat, I've tried so many different brands & styles. I thought for sure Dr Scholl's would be great but I was wrong. I really wanted to like these shoes and tried to get through one day of wearing them at my office but I just couldn't. Normally the first day of wearing new shoes is an adjustment but it's not supposed to be painful. I ended up putting on flip flops just to get through the day. I don't know if they just hit on the sides of my foot wrong but they were the most uncomfortable things I've ever worn. They were squeezing my foot all day, and I have narrow feet. Sad to return.

Shies are too wide. I tried returning them for a smaller size but they were still too wide!