Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Giorgie

I think these would be very comfortable if they were not so narrow in the front. The pointy toe makes the toe box too narrow for anyone with larger feet. Being that I am a size 11, they feel like I'm wearing heels, which totally defeats the purpose of wearing flats. And I didn't realize how bad they would be until I wore them at work all day, so now I'm stuck with a pair of shoes I can't wear. All in all I'd say they're good shoes, but if you are in the larger sizes, be careful! They need to widen the front a bit, or make it a bit longer, to accommodate the longer toes of people with larger feet.

If these are a size 10, then I've been lying to myself all of these years and I'm really a size 13. These were in no way a 10! I could barely get my heel into these.

Extremely uncomfortable to be a dr scholls product. I was excited about this flat for everyday office use, but disappointed when I tried them on. The material was cheap and almost had a sandpaper texture in the back on ankle. I will not try the brand again.

I've been looking for leopard flats for a while and finally took a chance on these because they were on sale. I've had Dr. Scholl's flats before with mixed results because their sizing and fit is pretty inconsistent. However, these fit just like my old black leather "Really" flats which were fantastic shoes! Obviously there is not much arch support in a flat, but the insoles have a nice bounce to them and I particularly like the little gel pads in the back of the shoe, which keeps your heel from rubbing on the back. Brilliant! Also not too much toe cleavage with this one. The edge hits right where my bunions are, but I think with some gentle break-in I won't notice that much longer. If you have serious bunion issues these might not be the cut for you, but you could also try the wide width. I'm normally an 8 or 8.5 and the 8.5 was perfect for this style (the 8's were too tight around the front edge and pinched my big toe).

Comfortable soles that mold to your feet, like many of Dr Scholls shoes! I thought they fit as expected. I definitely had to break them in though, so wear your band-aids the first few times out. Otherwise I really like the fit and the whiskey brown color pairs easily with most other colors.

These shoes are very elegant. However, not for people with long toes (like me!). The size was right but there wasn't enough space in the front of the shoe. If I'd gone a size up the my heel would slide out of the shoe. Good looking shoe, just not the right fit for me :)

When I first bought these shoes, I loved them. They are very comfortable and felt true to size (I am size 9). However, over time they started falling apart. I do not know how this happened because I usually wear these to work but after a few months of everyday wear this is what they look like. Save your money!

These shoes were great for a few months and then just fell apart- the inner lining disintegrated! So disappointing.

I bought these in hopes of finding a pair of comfortable flats for work. I tried to break them in and wore bandaids every timebut these cut the back of my heel and gave me corns on my toes. The sole is comfortable but even after breaking them in the shoes are ruining my feet :(

I wear black flats to work at least 2-3 days per week, so when my old pair wore out, I took the search for a new pair very seriously. I'm very happy with these. I wanted a pair with more support than average flats, and these have a nice cushiony foam insole, including extra foam at the arch for good support. I was also pleasantly surprised to find the heel also has some extra padding so that they don't fall off the heel. I'm always skeptical about shoes with a nice cushioned sole liking too matronly, but I think these still look good too. I like how far they come down over the toes (almost completely covered except for the small toes) and have have an almond-shaped toe box. I saw some reviews saying these ran small and considering ordering a 1/2 size up, but I'm glad I didn't. If anything they are a tiny bit large on me (but not enough to be a problem). The fabric lining rubbed a bit the first couple of times I wore them, but really they were easier to break in than most flats, in my experience. I'm so happy with these, I ordered another pair of Dr. Scholl's flats in a different color I found on sale on a different website. Definitely recommend.

I love these Dr. Scholl shoes. I have major foot issues and pain, and these are perfect for running around at work all day. I just wish they came in even more colors!

I was able to wear these shoes right out of the box with no break-in and no problems with fit and feel. However, that said, I normally wear a size 11 but would choose a 10-1/2 if I were to buy another pair---assuming that size was available. The stucco color I chose is more like a dark taupe but bends perfectly with my various tan, brown and green shades of pants or slacks. The "microsuede" upper finish is also very nice. If showing toe cleavage is no problem, these cute ballet flats are comfy for the office as well as for casual or dress up!

These stay on my feet, unlike similar flats. They are on the narrow side in the toe box and heel. I received several compliments on them, and really like the style. The sticker on the bottom says they are made of dyed cow hair, which sounds odd, but they look very natural. I definitely recommend trying them if you have trouble with flats slipping in the heel.

Surprisingly stylish for Dr. Scholl's, has more arch support than most flats and nice little "bumps" below ankels to keep heels from slipping. Thank you reviewers - I ordered the "wide" even though i'm usually a medium and they fit well. I'd say the length is a tiny bit on the shorter side - i'm usually and 8.5 to 9, I ordered the 9 W and they are just barely long enough.

Chic and comfortable. A shoe for elegance as well as walking.

Very stylish and well made. Super happy with this purchase. Best of all they’re vegan!

They fit perfectly and are super comfortable. Thank you.

These are greatâ?¦ The "whiskey" color style of these looks like they're leather but they're not (yay for compassionate choices!) and they were very comfortable from the first time I wore them. I thought they would be a little bit more of a "cognac" kind of orangish brown but I guess "whiskey" equals more of a medium brown...I guess all brown liquor colors are not the same - ha! But it doesn't matter - I'm so happy I bought these.

I usually wear a 10 1/2 but since this shoe doesn’t come in that size, and the reviews said it was tight in the front, I got a size 11. Well, I should have gotten the 10. I keep walking out of these.

I really wanted to like these, but they just bag out too much in the middle. I had to hold them on my feet.

I really wanted these to work. They were wide and looked stretched out when I stood up in them. Just had an awkward fit. Love the squishy comfy insert(s) in there but the frame of the shoe was just not right for me. I was a bit concerned also that the front of the shoe opening would rub. Love the look -- hate the fit.

The toe box was very tight. Had to return them.

I was so looking forward to getting these. At my job I can't wear sandals and I thought these would be PERFECT for working in the summer! These flats NEVERR get broken in. After a week it almost feels like they are somehow getting smaller?! They fit well but they will rub your ankles away. They also make weird noises when you walk? I've never been more dissapointed in something that was supposed to be comfortable.