Customer Reviews Drew Magnolia

I have very wide feet with very high insteps and am very hard to fit. I was soo excited to find the WW width. Shoes are very comfortable and will always get my shoes from Zappo's.

I have long, narrow, flat feet with a small bunion on one foot. Shoes are hard to find. These Drews are too clunky to be totally stylish, but--they stay on, I can walk comfortably in them, my orthotic inserts fit, and they don't hurt. The maryjane strap has sufficient Velcro to cinch in tightly. The fabric toe area stretches enough not to bind on a bunion. The double removable insoles make it possible to replace the top insole with my orthotics, keep the underlying insole for cushioning, and still have enough depth in the shoe. With my feet, I choose function over form, and these shoes make the cut.

This is a beautiful shoe and will help someone's aching feet but I am looking for a lighter shoe to take on a trip that includes a lot of walking. Found a Clark's that is much lighter for picking these feet up and down. Next time.

Though this shoe isn't super stylish, for someone with severe bunions, Morton's neuroma, super high instep and arch, and one hammer toe, it's a comfy shoe, in double wide width. Haven't had a chance to wear it out of the house yet, but from walking around hardwood floors, it seems like it'll work well. Note: the strap is too long, but I brought it to a seamstress who shortened it in five minutes, so not a big deal. I ended up buying two pairs in two different colors.

I really don't understand why we bigger footed women have such ugly shoe choices! These are the worst of the worst!! I need supportive shoes that I can wear orthotics in. If I wear a size 12 there are tons of nice choice. At size 13 there are only these clodhoppers?? Sheesh...really Drew??

Perfect for a person with swollen feet. Even strap worked for my 95 year old mother.

I picked the wrong size due to having a new AFO brace. It is extremely comfortable with the brace, but I am not sure I like the look of the shoe with the brace. I have both the brace and the sock liner showing through the opening on the Mary Jane. A cute and supportive shoe for the brace.

Too short and wide for me. Looks like a great shoe for anyone it fits.

These shoes are kind of cute (for an orthotic-friendly mary jane), although the fabric in front looks kind of grannyish. Still, they seemed comfortable and I'd probably have kept them if the fit had been better for me. I have a narrow heel but a medium forefoot, and the shape of this shoe did not work -- my heel was sliding out with each step.

The material that I was hoping had some give, to ease shoe pressure on my bunions, made my normally dry feet sweat. Shes will return to Zappo and I'll try a different style of Drew shoe. Really appreciate the free returns policy and quick shipping of orders. I have miserable feet that are about to go sight-seeing in Europe.

Many mfg's don't seem to understand that a larger foot does not mean thick ankles and heel! Sloppy big at the back...

I was very disappointed in these shoes. The area from the heel to the arch was huge, while the toe box fit ok. There is no shape to the shoe; it's basically a rectangle. I have a very pronounced bunion on my right foot, and these shoes did accommodate it. However, I could not keep them on my heel. Plus there is very little support in the shoe. Very disappointing considering the cost.

I can't say enough about this shoe. Everything is perfect. So perfect I have 4 pairs. It's the only thing I wear every day (unless snowing). I want to have enough shoes to last me incase they stop making them. I am still on one of the pairs bought 2 years ago. I love them.

My feet being long and narrow finding a shoe that fits and is comfortable after having four foot surgeries has been a frustrating problem. Then I found the Drew Magnolia. Although I have had problems finding shoes narrow enough this Mary Jane in the narrow with the adjustable strap allows me to snug up the shoe so it doesn't flop on my foot. Although not the most stylish shoe it is by far the most comfortable and I have two pairs of them. So glad I tried them.

Solid and well made for short

Too short in length.

A nice looking, sturdy walking shoe. I found it ran a bit short.

These were not the most stylish shoe but are very comfortable and supportive for my feet. I wear a size 13 M but have bunions and arthritis in my feet. Drew shoes are usually the best fitting shoes for me. The fabric is very comfortable and supportive for the top of my foot. The arch support was good too. They work for my feet but I wish they looked better on.

I LOVE any new Drew shoe that is pretty and decorative!!! These are very dressy! The lurex is nice and shiny. Please Drew, please keep designing pretty shoes for those of us who have to wear orthopedic shoes!

I LOVE these shoes! I REALLY LOVE these shoes. They are extremely comfortable and stylish. The Mary Jane styling can go with so many things. Absolutely wonderful!

Love the room in this shoe! I have an extra wide foot. A large toebox very comfortably fits. Material is kind of like wetsuit material. I wore it for an entire day-comfortably-the first day I had it. Not many shoes can do that!!

Although these looked nice the toe seems very long and I felt I would trip over it. otherwise they felt comfortable but a little wide at the strap.

I bought these in both 7.5 and 8 narrow. I am returning these because the size 8 fits better. I wear slim or extra slim shoes generally, but I have found that sometimes I can wear a narrow in Mary Jane shoes that have an adjustable strap. I have orthotics and usually remove the inserts so that the orthotics set flat in the foot bed. However, in order to get a width that was acceptable, I had to leave the inserts in the shoe.

I would like a stretch toe shoe for my Morton's neuroma and metatarsalgia, but this shoe does not have enough arch support for me, and the sole is somewhat slippery. I do not want to slip.

These shoes are great if you have bunions and I happen to have them on both sides of my foot. I love the flexibility of being able to adjust the velcro strap, without which I would step out of this shoe while walking. My only complaint and reason I gave this shoe 4 stars overall is the velcro strap is too long. I managed to attach the strap as far as possible without it touching the floor and is still almost too loose. With socks it will work fine, so I'm going to keep them. I have flat, wide feet and plantar fasciitis along with the bunions, so if you have problem feet this shoe is for you. The shoe is very comfortable and fits perfectly with my orthotics.