Customer Reviews SOREL Tofino II

I just received these in a size 7.5 in Black/Gum. There are TINY! I normally wear a size 6 and sometimes size up to 6.5 for running shoes or boots so I have a little more comfort. My foot is slightly wide but not so wide that I would wear a wide in shoes, wides are too wide for my feet. Based on other reviews, I purchased the 7.5 which is a whole size bigger than normal for boots for me. And these were still too small in length and too narrow in width. I'm trying to decide whether to exchange them for a size 8.5 or just return them altogether. I need waterproof boots since it looks like we're getting some snow and my old snow boots are not so waterproof any more... I hope this review helps others with sizing. The frustrating part of buying shoes online is always the fit!

These boots are very stiff and made my legs look huge!

Too small.

These boots did not fit. I am returning them. They are too small.

Very small, even with no socks on. Would recommend sizing up 1/2 to one full size up.

stiff and uncomfortable fit. The faux fur is already shedding.

These were very stiff and hard to walk in. I can’t imagine wearing them in snow. The toe box is narrow, not comfortable at all. Very disappointed as Sorel is highly rated. Returned.

My feet aren't wide yet this boots felt tight even with no socks on. They also squeaked when I walked around the house with them on. I tried ordering a half size up but the width didn't improve.

These are beautiful boots. However, they actually fit almost a whole size too small and to my amazement they are even narrower than the pair I have now.

Not as comfortable as my current Tofino boots. I ordered two colors to decide on to replace my existing boots that I love and have had for about ten years. These are shorter and the foot bed feels very hard. So they went back.

the calf part sticks out so much, not sure who this is made for, but if you have average or slightly large calves, it will be WAY too wide...Otherwise they look nice

I wear a 7.5 .... the 7.5 gave me a KILLER heel blister. Like - had to return them. Backs are very stiff. Not great.

I really wanted to love these boots, they looked so cute. One big plus for them is traction, they were great on ice. I am a childcare provider and walk outside for several miles everyday, so I need warmth, comfort and traction. Unfortunately even with mild weather 30 degrees my feet were not warm. Also the laces are a waxy material that will not stay tied, constantly having to retie.

These boots are fashionable. But they do NOT keep my feet warm. Why should I size up to add extra socks if these are meant to be snow boots? The top is a plastic-like rubber, not the heavy-duty type of rubber the other heavier styles like the Winter Carnival or the Caribou styles I have, Those are snowboots. I have tried many times to wear them because they are so cute. But then 15 mins out of the house and my feet are cold.I could not imagine wearing them in the snow. Why can Sorell get this boot right, stylish and warm? Finally had to give them away. I would not recommend it these Torino I have other Sorels I LOVE! like Joan of Arc lace-up wedge.

love this boot, BUT... I usually love any Sorel product I buy, this boot has very poor insulation. I am replacing an old pair that I have had for over 10 years that finally lost their waterproofing, but this boot makes my toes cold unlike my 10 year old pair. VERY disappointed with this particular product for that fact only.

I’m very disappointed in these shoes! They are not very warm and have stretched out big time! I normally wear a size 9 and so that’s what I bought. At first they felt too tight across the top so I tried breaking them in by walking around my house and after a few days they felt great!! So I wore them outside in the snow. Over the last few I’ve worn them I notice them feeling bigger and bigger each time so I keep wearing thicker and thicker socks each time to accommodate the larger feeling shoe. Do to the bigger shoe the sides have started to buckle as well because I keep having to tighten the shoe strings! The only reason I give them two stars is because the shoes are so cute!! I’m totally bummed out about this. These are $170 shoes that I’ve worn only a hand full of times and they look and feel like they are 5 years old!! Maybe I just got a bad pair who knows!