Customer Reviews Jerusalem Sandals The Good Shepherd - Womens

Loved the style and quality and color. However the top strap was too low for my high arches and I could not even get them all the way on.

The leather is beautiful and the sole is comfortable, but the straps do run wide. So for the right person/foot, these are a good purchase.

I love these. They are very comfortable -no problems with the leather between the toes for me. Easy slip on and go sandals. Look cute with skirts, jeans, shorts. I have the brown ones, which are a deep rich oxblood color. Well made. Glad I got them.

oddly a bit large. I wear a 7 and 1/2 and European sizing can often run a bit small/tight for me with the 38 and the next size up too big--these oddly ran “sloppy”. Sending them back...

Initially I just thought they were too big because my foot went pass the edge, but tried them again. The length is good, but the straps are all too loose. Size down will not work.

I loved how these sandals looked in the online photos. The length of the sandal is perfect, although it's a bit on the narrow side. The issue that I personally had is that the straps are quite loose. The strap that goes over the top of the foot is SUPER long. If you have rather pudgy feet they might work. I personally have a thinner foot, so unfortunately they won't work. As far as sizing, I typically wear an 8.5-9. I ordered these in size 9. As I mentioned before, the length is good, but the sole runs narrow. I hope this review will help others. Thanks.

I wear 11M and these sandals felt half size smaller. I do love the style of the shoe - very cute - but the leather is very stiff. Don't want to risk getting possible bruises on my feet while waiting for leather to soften with wear. In my opinion shoes have to fit and feel good right out of the box; these did not do it for me. Sadly, they go back. Thank you Zappos for your outstanding return policy!

the part of the shoe where the big toe goes rubbed where toe meets the foot every time you walk. It looks nice on but really hurt after walking around for a minute. leather quality is very good.

I liked the way they looked but I could barely put my foot into the sandal! They seem to run very narrow and I returned them.

Really like the feel and style of this sandlot but unfortunately the black dye wears off and turns the bottom of my feet black, even after several wears.

These shoes were very beautiful, elegant, and had that "earthy" style that I love. However, when I tried them on, my foot slid forward too far on the left shoe when I walked, causing my toes to hang over the front edge. It wasn't, that I needed a bigger size, because there was plenty of room in the back. If only the shoe had a bigger front area, in front of the toe loop to accommodate the length of my toes, I would have kept these!

I wanted a pair of blue leather sandals and these were just what I wanted, however when I put them on the toe ring really digs into my foot. I'm still on the fence about whether I want to return them or keep them and try to have them fixed at a shoe repair shop because other than that they are really nice - but I'm starting to lean toward returning them. Sad because I do love them.

I have very skeletal feet so I could feel the strap attachment under the footbed. The color is too orange for me.

Very cute sandal but as others have stated, the leather looks so beat up and the color is uneven. There's even glue marks on the side. I understand the Jerusalem look but this is too rough looking. Zappos makes returning so easy. Love them!

felt to wide, not a comfortable fit, the right shoe was wider. would like to return

I generally wear an 8.5-9 and based on reviews ordered a 9.... couldn't even get my foot in them!!!! I would need a 10-10.5 easily which is insane. Extremely disappointed.

Really cute but... well the left shoe was defective as the leather was not dyed grey in all areas. It looked pretty bad. I got to looking at the right shoe and not only was there a large glob of dried glue on the side of the shoe, but the ridge where the shoe meets the sole was not dyed either and the right sole is higher on the right shoe than the left. It looks like these were made by a blind person. Really bad quality. Willing to give it another chance though, so called to order another pair.