Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Carrin

SO CUTE but HORRIBLE fit. I have tiny feet, narrow, size 5.5... ordered a 5.5 and 5 due to reviews about sizing. The 5.5 was so tight, but was slipping off. The 5...couldn't even get my foot in the shoe! No choice but to send them back

Cute shoe, but it just doesn't fit my foot right. I have a wide foot. I usually wear a 7.5 to an 8. I ordered an 8 wide and could barely get my foot in. I then ordered an 8.5 W and it was still too narrow in the front, but my heel slipped terribly because the shoe was now too long, and the canvas heel doesn't really grasp the foot. Returned both sizes.

Loved the look of these shoes, however they were too wide for my narrow feet! I had to return them!

very cute shoes however not meant for a busy day wear! the sole of the shoe is thick and hard as they are platform shoes. though it makes them look very appealing but they are least flexible and very difficult to walk in. the back of the shoe kept coming off as i start to walk because of the hard and heavy bottom. the designer didn't think of wearability at all. not good enough for me! returning them!!

Oh no...these are the cutest shoes with the worst fit! Just standing in them, I had enough room in the back and ankle area to fit a rolled up sock. Not only couldn’t I manage keeping them on as I walked, they looked crazy big. Disappointed

These shoes run wide and are very firm and not flexible on the bottom. I found they made walking awkward.

love the look, however, heel slides too much and a smaller size would be too short. Toe looked to rounded.

Oh I wanted to like these. So pretty and when you stand in them, they feel good. Until ... you take you first step and they are so heaven that the soles stay on the ground and you beheld lifts up and out of the shoe. There's something wrong with the design when the shoe doesn't come with you.

Very cute shoe but my heels slipped out with every step. Had to return b/c they wouldn't stay on.

I really love the style of this show. Unfortunately I have to return it because it's way too narrow for a Wide shoe. Disappointed :(

Terrible toxic chemical smell coming from shoes. Returned

I previously purchased this same shoe, Carrin size 8W, in both saddle & dusty rose and have been very happy with them. Since the black shoe went on clearance, I was looking forward to having a third pair and saving a couple of $. Oddly, even tho the first two pair fit perfectly, and this pair is marked as the same size, they are so narrow and noticeably shorter in length so there is no chance of being able to wear them.

the fit was WAY smaller than expected at least one size smaller than stated. could not get my foot into it, therefore, I could not tell anything about it

I am so disappointed that these shoes fell apart because I really did LOVE them. The color, the fit, the style are all PERFECT. However, the side of the shoe and the top of the shoe completely came apart after one wearing.

Not pleased with the quality. They came unsewn pretty quickly, only worn a few times .

I bought this item 3 times - first time it was way too big - 2nd time from wide to medium width i could not get this black one on and since i bought the putty color which fits perfectly in the medium width i tried again to purchase the medium width in black but again could not even get either shoe on - very disappointed - guess i was not meant to own/wear this shoe in black!

I really wanted to love these shoes but they ran and 1/2 size small and are pretty narrow. Also, my heel kept slipping because of how heavy the shoe is. Returned immediately

I have now ordered this shoe in a 9 which was too small, the 10 which was too big and the 9.5 determined that it would have to fit me. I have returned all 3 frustrated because I love the shoe!!! I'm trying the 9 and 91/2 in the wide and remain hopeful. I have never ordered a W in a shoe.

super tight on width and I don't have a wide foot.

I got these in the cheetah print and I so wanted to love them. They looked great on but were ill-fitting and wouldn't stay on. I think the weight of the heavy sole pulls the shoe off your feet. I was sad to return them.

Adorable shoes but the wide fits like a narrow medium width shoe.

I was so looking forward to getting these shoes; however, I ordered my size 6 and couldn't even get them on my feet. Very dissapointed

I wore them once and the stitching came out. They literally fell a part. I’m a huge Sam Edelman fan but this shoe is junk. I’m extremely disappointed.

I ordered the black suede and loved it after a couple of wearings. Then ordered the multicolored and love the look but it is so narrow and tight I am returning. Truly, I would be screaming if I tried to wear this shoe. I even double checked the label on the box and in the shoe to make sure it was a M and it was - but doesn’t fit that way and I tried it on this morning before my feet had swollen in our 100 degree heat. Very disappointing because I really wanted an all purpose color shoe.

So I have three pairs, I love them that much... BUT beware! They are totally inconsistent in size... one fits me in an 8.5, the other two I needed 9's, then I bought another color in 9 and the left is bigger than the right, and now I don't know if I should exchange them for another 9 or an 8.5! Super annoying, but once you get the right fit, they're so cute. Worth the hassle.