Customer Reviews Birkenstock Ashley

I ordered these in the silver so I'd have something comfortable but slightly dressier than my normal Birkenstocks for work. They fit the bill there and look good with almost everything. As far as fit, I can wear either a narrow or wide in Birkenstocks though I usually find the wide to be more comfortable. I'd say my feet are a standard medium in most brands. These do fit me, though as other reviewers note the Narrow in this style isn't comparable to the Narrow in other Birkenstock sizes. However I think most people who wear a medium width could probably wear these. My only complaint is that the leather on the straps is already fraying a bit, after only 3-4 wears. I think it's just so soft it pulls apart when I pull in and out of the buckle. It's almost like the straps weren't properly finished. Hopefully it stops after a little more wear. Beyond that, I really like the shoe. Not comfortable in the same way as other Birkenstocks but as they have a different footbed I didn't expect the same fit. Very comfortable for a sandal with a bit of a wedge heel.

For the most part, I love the feel and fit if this shoe, the esp. footbed as it is contoured like a classic Birkenstock, though these are quite a bit more narrow---which for me is ideal (traditional Birkenstocks were always too wide). One PROBLEM : the thong separator between the toes is made out of a hard plastic and not at all comfortable . I wore these all day in the house and finally put some soft fabric around the plastic to cushion my toes. I guess it was worth it to me to keep these sandals as they have the right kind of support for my feet, hard to find in other sandals.

These are beautiful stylish comfortable shoes. However, my pinky toes were laying off the shoe. They are so narrow not all of your beautiful toes will have a place to rest on them.

Super cute, but super disappointed. This shoe only comes in narrow. That is my only complaint. I have 6 pair (different color or style) of birkenstock sandals and I love love love them. So, I was excited to see a wedge! I ordered the same size as all of my other birkenstock sandals (yes, I saw that narrow was the only width option -- I was being super hopeful!!). Not only did the sandal fit too narrow, but way to short! I exchanged them for one size bigger; I could hardly tell any difference from the first pair. Sadly, the second pair is going back too. Unless you have a very narrow foot, this super cute sandal is NOT for you!

Shoe is too narrow even though I wear a narrow and the silver is just too bright for my use.

This sandal is so comfortable. Great arch support. A little slimmer than a typical Birkenstock which was nice. However, the strap that went around the back of my heel was very large with no way to adjust it. Returned these.

These would be great shoes if the thong was leather instead of hard plastic. I am very disappointed. I will be returning these.