Customer Reviews TOMS Classic Alpargata

I thought I'd give these a try on my weird feet - some reviews said they ran large/wide, but no not so much. If you have wide feet, you'll want to skip these. They mean what they say when they say "M." I'm sure they'll be comfy for someone to run around in, though...sending them back.

I wear a 5-51/2 in shoes with a narrow heel. I cannot wear TOMS because of my narrow heel. I ordered this shoe in 2 sizes and both too loose in the heel. Even heel grips won't help. TOMS fit narrow in the footbed and wider in the heel.

Fit way bigger than my usual size and style. Sent back

very small

fit fine but not as comfortable as Toms Cloud shoe

This shoe was huge on my daughter, who wears a 12 sneaker. Maybe we are just not used to Tom’s fit, but we are trying a size down, since she likes the style.

I love Tom's but this pair was at least a full size too large. They were too long and too baggy. They were unwearable. Unusual for Tom's.

These are not the same Classic Alpargata I ordered and loved from a few years ago...sadly, like so many shoe products, the companies change the way they manufacture and YUCK. Just not the same. Footbed is not nearly as nice or supportive - the white bottom is ugly - just awful.

Runs small size up x2 if you have fat feet.

HOping to love these shoes but are being sent back. Look cheap and squeak when I walk.

these are more brown than ash --- true ash from wood burning is grey, not brown

I don't understand why these are so popular? I purchased a pair so that I would have some casual slip on shoes. Appearance-wise, they look true to the photos. They are horribly uncomfortable; a good half-size smaller, no inner support. I wore them for a few hours, thinking that they would stretch a little after the first couple wears (they did not). The thing that disappointed me the most was the fact that the bottoms of the shoes have no traction at all, so I was slipping and sliding the whole time.

These seem so cheaply made compared to my other Toms. The inside edge has a seam that ribs against my inner heel and now both feet have tender spots. These shoes are going to the donation pile.

I wanted these shoes to work so badly! They say “true to size” so I got size 10 bc I’m usually a 9.5 - 10. Way too big! Tried 9.5. Still too big. Tried 9. Still sleeps off my heel :( Maybe I just have really skinny heels. I’m giving up for now. So disappointed and don’t understand how I’m always a 9.5 - 10 yet I may be an 8 or 8.5 in this shoe.