Customer Reviews OluKai Pehuea

I ordered these shoes in both a 9 only to have them be too small. So, I sent them back and ordered a 9.5, which also turned out to be too small. To be quite honest, I could not tell the difference. They felt like the same size length wise, with the 9.5 being a bit wider. I've never worn a size 10 in my life so after ordering, returning, ordering and now returning again, I'm not sure it's worth the hassle for me to order a size 10 - the 9.5 was already a little on the wide side for me. Sizing definitely seems off here. Every pair of shoes I own is a size 9 and I have never worn a larger size. With both sizes, my big toe was right up against the front, no extra space at all. I'm super disappointed as they are very cushioned and appear to be very comfortable. I love the style as well and think these would make a perfect warm weather shoe for when you need something other than sandals. I was purchasing these to replace my go to TOMS trvl lite slip on sneaker (which I love but they no longer seem to make).

This shoe was so cute, but unfortunately I had to return both the size 11 which was too big and the size 10 which was too small. Why don't they make a 10.5 which probably would of been perfect.

The shoe seemed very wide and therefore was difficult to judge fit. Loved the style. Returned.

I ordered the shoe in moss/palm, and it is really attractive! That made it all the more disappointing that it simply did not fit: Too tight with a sock, and without, it rubbed very uncomfortably at the unpadded heel collar. I returned the item.

The top edges of the shoe that lay against the ankle were tough and scratchy. I was expecting better for the price, so I returned them.

Sadly I returned these, I have owned the same shoe for several years and loved them. Thought it was time for a new pair, but they fit different and for some reason they make a loud clomping noise when walking. Too expensive to put up with that. Maybe it was just this particular pair that was defective in some way.

These shoes were very cute. But I’m over 65...I want more support than this shoe offered. Also, I like sneakers that are strong enough around the edges that I can slip my feet into them without bending down. The edges of these did have the strength to stand up to slipping my foot in without assistance.

Nice pair of loafers but I wish I could return this slip-on! I thought if I wore it for a few times it would help break it in but I was wrong, this shoe is too narrow for my feet, after wearing them to work my little toe was so swollen. This shoe is comfortable and stylish but the width is for someone with skinny feet. Unfortunately for me, I cannot return it! $79.95 wasted!

I do not like these as well as the leather shoe. They are somewhat abrasive on my feet so I have to wear a sock liner with them. I can wear my leather ones without socks and they are much softer and more comfortable. Love the look and color of this one but disappointed that I cannot wear without a sock.

I liked the style but the fit was not comfortable. The left shoe was loose and larger than the right. The material felt somewhat stiff.

Cute shoe, but ran big and stretched too easily

Cute shoes but sending them back since they are too small. Ordered a 9 since I wear an 8, 8.5 but the 9 s were too small in length.

This shoe is super cute, unfortunately the size was off for me. I’m always a size 6, however, that was too big. Unfortunately, they do not make a size 5.5 and the 5 is too smaller.

Too big, going back!

I love the style so I am keeping them, but they are too big in the heel and the slip off. I tried heel pads but they make them too tight so I am letting them slip off a little v

Too small and too short. I am sending them back. Sorry

I wear a 7 and had to order a 37.5. I have flat feet and these have great support. My only issue is that I have had these shoes for only 6 weeks and my toe has already poked a hole in the mesh top. For $85 I would think they would be more durable.

These shoes are so cute and got great reviews. I really wanted to love them, but the sizing just didn't work for me. I wear a 5 1/2 which Olukai doesn't make. Unfortunately, the 6 was too big, and the 5 was too small. Plus my ankles slid right out of the shoes when I walked. I see that several other reviewers had the same problem, so anyone with narrow ankles might want to pass on these or just bend down the back part to wear as mules.

I ordered two pairs of these shoes and the black pair had to be returned because they were too narrow. I kept the sage green pair and they fit and feel great.

The shoe was comfortable to walk on, but seemed too short in the toe box. A half size up would have slipped off my heel. I returned them, but my husband was so impressed that he purchased a similar men's style for himself. Cute style, great insole, but not quite right for my foot

These are cute but run narrow, really rounded toe box

These shoes are very supportive and accommodate a high instep, but I have to return them because they run narrow. I wear a size 11 and my feet are wide, I wore them around my house to test them out and ended up with red and blistered feet. If you have normal or narrow feet, I highly recommend them. Otherwise, look elsewhere.

I purchased this shoe in 7 and 7 1/2. The 7 was too small so I keep the 7 1/2. I have worn these shoes for the last two months and they seem to have stretched in length. I now have to wear a sock to help keep them on my feet. I really like these shoes and get a lot of compliments on them, but the seem to grow after a few months

The top edge of the sole is very hard and my bunion sits right against it, so no go for me. I normally wear an 8, but I think I would go a half size up on this shoe.

just sent these back. Too small, big toe was was tight. They fit well on the rest of my foot so going up a 1/2 size would make them too large. I ordered a 7.