Customer Reviews Sperry Koifish Core

The only option I would love better would be the three ring option with the all black

I didn’t like the look of these shoes with pants as it was difficult to keep my socks from showing. I prefer shoes you can wear with socks so I returned these.

I got these for school because we have to wear brown/black leather shoes and these were amazing!

Love the shoes! Very comfortable and I absolutely love that they carry them in wide size. Would give them a 5, but they stained my nails. But overall love the west and style!

You can never go wrong with sperry

I have narrow feet and have so much trouble buying shoes. I have owned many Sperry shoes over the years. When I saw this shoe in black, I couldn't resist. I bought two sizes: 6.5 medium (which I have been able to wear in the past) and 7 slim. I kept the slim. It fits my skinny, flat feet well. I returned the 6.5M as they were too short. Love the black! Can wear much more often.

As several other reviewers have mentioned, this style fits narrow. I've never worn a Wide shoe, but I probably should have ordered it in this style. I'm currently wearing the shoes in the house for a few hours a day hoping to stretch them out - very tight across the instep! I held these shoes next to my last pair (Bluefish style- that is no longer offered) and there is quite a difference in the width of the two shoes. I wish Sperry had added a comment in the details of the shoe that if you're hoping to get the Bluefish fit, order this one in a wide.

I originally purchased my sperrys about two years ago and have been wearing them consistently for that length of time. I do have a few issues with the shoes. One issue being that when I do wear them I get blisters on my heels. At first I thought it was because they were new, but it has been occurring for two years now. Also I do wear the half socks with them and tie the top. The next issue that has occurred is that I can visually see the bottom of the shoe (rubber yellow tan) part separating from the side (leather looking part). I do know that the shoes are stitched in and will hopefully not come apart from the shoe its self. I do believe that they are a great pair of shoes and are extremely stylish! I was also wondering if you have any tips to washing the shoes? They are not that dirty but do have a small stain on the toes part which is totally my fault and I am in no way giving the shoes a lower score because of it. Thank you for your time!

I have bought these shoes before and will buy more in the future. I love these shoes and the many different styles and colors.

I used to get the Bluefish and opted for this model this time. Style-wise, very similar - classic, clean. Comfortable, although a little stiff and needs some wearing-in when first purchased. Seems to run a bit more narrow than the Bluefish, especially in the toe box. I have somewhat narrow feet and wear a narrow in other styles, but did not need a narrow for the Koifish. Overall, I am pleased with the product.

I loved the style and comfort but the size was one size too big.

Runs a size small and has a narrow fit. Go up a size

I've worn Sperry boat shoes (the basic original) for over 30+ years and prefer the leather lining. The lining on this shoe is not leather . . and I miss it!

I was hoping that these shoes were like other Sperry shoes that I have. My others had removable insoles so that I can put in necessary orthotics. I will continue to check the site for other shoes as they come out.

I had to return these. I have bought Sperry boat shoes for years. These are extremely narrow! I ordered medium width, there is no way they are medium width. they are painfully narrow. I am exchanging them for a larger size to see if that helps.

A little tight. I know they need to stretch, but they're uncomfortable.

I like them enough to keep them but very disappointed. I have a pair I got probably 6-7 years ago that has a wider opening and smaller toe box that I like much better. It's a much cuter shoe than these I just purchased.

Your delivery and response time was great and the shoes were beautiful. But they were incredibly narrow. I had to return them. Why can you not make boat shoes in wide width?

I have somewhat narrow feet so I was hoping having laces would make them fit. One did and one seemed much wider - so I wondered if that was an indication of what would happen when they stretched out. They didn't have enough support for the amount of walking at my job, either. Sperry has so many cute styles but now that I've tried them, I don't think I can wear them.

Had to switch to a wide, which I've never used before. Always been an average/medium width. Shoe is hard to break in and make it comfortable. Waiting for cooler weather to wear with socks with hope of making them more comfortable.

This great looking pair of shoes need to be broken in. Width is great but the stiff left heel left me blistered and bleeding.

They are ok, somewhat cute i suppose. I bought them for work and im on my feet all day they tore up the back of my heel and i had sox on with them. I have like kinda wide feet and the regular width ones look kinda stupid because they are so narrow. Oh and they dyed my sox and feet black thats not a deal breaker for me but it might be for someone else.