Customer Reviews Naturalizer Michelle

These shoes look very cute on.

These are my new go to work shoes. I have them in multiple colors because now putting on any other type of high heel feels horrible. Don’t get me wrong, wearing these are not the same level of comfort as wearing your Nikes, but we are talking about high heels here and out of all the high heels I’ve purchased in my days, these are by far the most comfortable. I did have to buy a wide because I found the regular too narrow but I have huge feet, size 12, so it very well could have just been that.

Gorgeous shoe! Heel slips on my narrow feet, so I have to return them. WAH!!

Cute shoe but my heel slipped.

Too snug across the top of the foot. Going to try a half-size larger and see if I have better luck.

Loved the shoe! Heel was too big even ordering a narrow.

Loved the shoes but my foot kept coming out of the left shoe.

These shoes are comfortable immediately out of the box. Second pair of this shoe and I will keep reordering as long as they make them! Classic style, very comfortable.

Nice shoe.

So cute but they run wide! I wear an 8AA in most shoes, a 7.5 AA in Naturalizer but these were too wide.

The best work shoes I own, and I have a lot! As a flight attendant I have owned probably close to 40 pairs of black pumps ranging from $30-$150 and nearly every brand. These are the most comfortable and pretty of the bunch. I refuse to wear the clog type shoe (a lot of FA's wear) and will continue to wear a heel while I can. These deliver in the style comfort department! True to size, absolutely the best of the bunch.

Too Small - but I love these shoes - wish I could find them in a 10.

I tried a bunch of different pumps looking for one that fit, and this style was the winner. My dream size in a pump is 5 E/WW; Naturalizer doesn't offer any widths other than M in sizes smaller than a 6 (what's up with that, Naturalizer?) but their pumps run small/short, so I tried this style in 6W and it was a keeper. The toe box is perfectly cut, so no toe cleavage. The soles are grippy and the small platform makes the 3" heel as comfortable as a heel can be. But the real star of these pumps is the insoles: super cushioned in the right places and ACTUAL ARCH SUPPORT! In a pump! I didn't think it was possible. I tried this style in a bunch of different uppers; all were high-quality. I love these shoes! Color notes: the Chai is light and metallic, not at all glossy. The suedes are classy and just what you'd expect. The Black/Gold is a gorgeous party shoe. The iridescent Black and Taupe have subtle rainbow sparkles (I know how that sounds, but they're actually lovely - those are the two I ended up keeping). If you like this shoe but it runs a little wide/short for you, try the Naturalizer Natalie - it's a narrower, longer, pointy toed version with the same comfy insole.

It's a lovely shoe and very comfortable. Someone else commented that different colors seemed to be sized differently. The 8.5M in black felt a half size too big and the 8M in nude felt a half size too small. I'm going to try the black in an 8M and hope it fits. If that works, I'll give the nude color another go.

Someone else commented that different colors seemed to be sized differently. The 8.5 in black felt a half size too big and the 8M in nude felt a half size too small. I'm going to try the black in an 8M and hope it fits. It's a lovely shoe and very comfortable.

I've been looking for a stylish and comfortable neutral shoe for two years and I'm so happy I finally found these!

Wow! After I found the right size, it was like magic when I put them on. I have bunions and therefore need wide width to accommodate the bottom of my feet. But often they’re either too wide or just wide enough but then the heel slips. I range between a 9.5-10 and normal or wide width depending on the shoe. I tried the 9.5W and they were a little too snug so I went up to 10 W. They were perfect. And comfortable! Even with a 3 inch heel! I have found my perfect pump. Definitely planning to get more colors.

Great shoe but I did get a wide it still felt a little tight on the width

Notwithstanding I ordered WW rather than my normal W, this shoe was very narrow in the toe box.

I bought these in narrow and they fit my skinny feet perfectly. Sometimes with narrow shoes I need to buy a half size up, so I started with that and ended up stepping down to my regular size. They are SOOOOOOO comfortable. The entire toe box has a nice cushy bottom and there's a shocking amount of support in the arch. The rubbery sole and not-too-high heels make them incredibly easy to walk in. The color is exactly as pictured online. I bought them in light blue for my wedding and could not be happier. I feel confident I'll be comfortable for the entire event.

Execellent