Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gilroy

This is a great shoe that seems to go with anything from shorts to jeans to a sundresses. The thong between the toes sits a little far forward which I always find with Sam Edelman sandals. The ankle strap helps to keep your toes from creeping forward. The footbed is nicely padded and very comfortable. I had foot surgery on my right foot so I struggle finding comfortable shoes, these are great in that department. Made very well. I typically wear a 7.5 in open toe sandals but because the toe thong is so far forward on my foot, a 7 would have worked better.

I am really enjoying these sandals and have received so many compliments. They have been surprisingly comfortable and I feel quite stylish in them!

I am a size 9 narrow and the 8 1/2 fit perfectly. There is elastic on center straps that allows for expansion, if needed, but in my case, the straps were the right height/width. They are very comfortable and work well with a variety of outfits. Based on reviews and the fact that I can sometimes wear an 8 1/2 in open toe shoes, I purchased the 8 1/2 and it fit perfectly. The 9 would've left too much sandal in front of my toes.

I ordered the Polish Metallic. I am a 7.5 B and these fit perfectly. They are the most comfortable sandals I own. I have walked a lot in them with no problems.

These sandals are gorgeous! I got the yellow and gold (2 pair) and couldn't be happier! The color combinations are perfect and make a plain outfit stand out. Great job Sam Edelman!

These are great sandals that work with just about any summer outfit. I would give 5 stars but they fit loosely if you have narrow feet.

I loved these shoes but they ran SO big. I always wear a 7.5 and I had to return twice for a 6.5 and then a 6. Make sure you order an entire size down. Other than that the shoe is super cute and quality made!

Very unusual fit. Sandal felt one half size larger. I don't have what would be described as a pudgy foot. However, the straps were very tight across the top of my foot. If my feet were to swell, these would have been unbearably uncomfortable. Cute style but I had to return.

I absolutely love the look of these sandals, and they look amazing on my feet. However, the toe area where it's pointed tended to drag when I walked in these. I could see them wearing down right there after time. And in the inside strap where there's elastic, the stitches rub against my inner feet...definitely a blister possibility there. And I'm so bummed about it! I really wanted to keep these.

These were very cute, but the straps that cross the middle of the foot were totally loose on me. They looked ridiculous, and I had to return the sandals.