Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Tabor Dress Plain Toe Oxford

Pros - width on my sole is fine. Look sharp, comfortable, and are NOT made in a Communist dictatorship (China, Vietnam) Con- to get the right width, the heel is a bit roomy. This is a common problem for me. I will get heel pads to take up a bit if room

Great fit, but much lighter brown than anticipated. Still great shoes. Returned only because the color was lighter than I wanted.

Overall these shoes are great. Especially for the price. I've literally been through about 10 pairs from Zappos and these are the first that feel right, don't wear out quickly, and check most of the boxes.

Great looking shoe. Based on previous reviews citing smaller than normal sizing, I purchased a half size larger. They fit perfectly. Slight break in time, but afterwards very comfortable.

Buying shoes is difficult for me as I have one foot that is slightly longer and narrow and one foot that is short and slightly thicker. I do not fit well in B width, but I need a narrow D. These run a little narrow and work well for my fit needs. I also like the simple classic look. Have not had them long so cannot comment on how well they hold up or keep a shine.

I like the color, style and fit of these shoes. The only oddity was the shoes laces were two different colors. Dark brown, almost black, on one shoe and a decidedly lighter brown on the other. Hmmm

Nice cushion but I was looking for something that looked more stylish and dressy.

Too loose in the heel.

Very comfortable. Definitely a dark tan rather than brown. The sole was much wider than normal and made the appearance a bit odd. I sent them back

I ordered the Tan color shoe, but got one several shades lighter, more Cognac than Tan. Good looking shoe, well constructed, but not comfortable to wear, due to a rigid sole, I think. At $ 100, this shoe was twice as expensive as my last pair from Stafford, but no where as comfortable.

The back is poor constructed. There is a fat lip around the opening, especially at the heel. I wanted to take them off as soon as I put them on.

My usual size is 9.5, so I ordered size 9 and size 9.5 to try since this is my first time buying this brand. Size 9 is exactly identical to 9.5 in dimensions!

WAY WAY too narrow.

To tight for me.

The color in the box is much more tan than the color in the photo. I've owned quite a few of these shoes over the years, which were all the picture's color. This is no longer true.

These shoes seemed to fit at first, but after wearing them I realized they were too large