Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

These shoes are cute and true to size, but like everyone else said, they're so stiff I couldn't get past that and had to send them back. I didn't feel like taking the chance that they "might" break in with time because my poor feet would suffer during the break in attempt.

I thought the quality of the printing on fabric looked a little cheap in person but not terrible. The heel is much wider than I would've liked. Length seemed true to size.

The size 8 was too small, the 8.5 too large.

Wore three times and the rubber sole is started to fall apart. (See pic) I wore these to work a few times, I have a pretty sedentary job, sit at a desk primarily, and today I notice the sole is falling apart. They are cute, and with no-show socks they are very comfy, but not worth the price since they are already falling apart.

These are so cute and I was excited they came in a wide width; however, the heel kept slipping off no matter what insoles and shoe pads I added, so I had to return them. This seems to be an ongoing problem with wide widths.

These shoes are really cute, but way too tight. I wear an 8.5 M, but this style is too narrow. I would have tried either an 8.5 W or 9, but neither size were in stock. These went back.

These shoes run wide even when I tried a 1/2 size smaller. They were stylish and cute but had return because of the poor fit.

disclaimer...when reviewing the fit of these shoes, i said they felt 1/2 size larger as well as wider. ONLY THE RIGHT SHOE FELT LIKE THAT. that's not an issue i've EVER HAD, with any shoe. i'm returning and ordering again...hoping it was a fluke. we shall see. other than that fairly serious issue, the shoes seemed great. very cute and felt well cushioned.

These shoes are so cute and I really wish they had fit better. I ordered an 8W and the width was perfect but they were too long. I sent them back for a 7W and the length is perfect but they are so tight I can not even wiggle my toes. I wore them around the house to see if they would stretch but they are just way too tight.

I wear a standard size 6 and purchased the grey flannel. These were incredibly tight all the way around the top of my foot when I first got them but they loosened up after the first wear. The length of my foot fit into the loafers but also a bit tighter than usual, my big toe bumps against the front of the show. If you're on the cusp of a size, maybe order the next size up. The foot bed was very cushioned, the flannel material was nice and otherwise a nice casual shoe that could feel like a sneaker but not be a sneaker. I knew the next size would be too big for me and I thought they would loosen over a few wears, which they did but I wish I had returned them and gotten another pair of Sofft loafers. The Sofft brand loafers are so much better, soft, comfortable and well sized for my foot.

These are really cute but they are a little loose in the heel. I don't have any other slip on shoes so it may just be that my instep is lower so the heel slips when I walk but I think I can fix that with some insoles. Otherwise, they are really comfortable and very cute. I considered sending them back for a smaller size but I don't think that would have made any difference.

The description of this shoe says, "Breathable textile." The fabric over the front of the foot is definitely vinyl, and I am afraid it will not breathe. Also, the footbed is squishy and comfortable, but I didn't find it to have any arch support, which is what I need more. The toe of the shoe is a little tight, but perhaps they would have stretched some and been okay. These are reasons that I'm sending them back.

Like the look of the shoe, but my 6.5 shoe was too tight. Returned.

i’m having to return these shoes. The heel slips off with every single step.

I was so excited when I received the box with these shoes! The color and style were just what I wanted. However, they were so hard to get on, even with a thin sock, because they were so narrow. I am a true size 7 and though I was able to get my foot into these shoes, it was very tight and felt very narrow. I quickly took them off after two steps and will be returning them. I recommend getting a half size to a size bigger and maybe a bit wider.

Returned the shoes immediately. With hammertoe and bunion, the shoes did not fit at all. One shoe seemed larger than the other one. One shoe was perfect in length but the other shoe extended about a half inch past my heel. Very uncomfortable in the toe box and no stretch to provide any comfort. They were delivered quickly and the return process was no hassle.

This shoe runs large. I wear a size 7 or 7 1/2. Too wide across the top Not my style.

Right length, but heel slips while toe bed not wide enough. Lacked enough arch. Very squeaky on wood floors