Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

This is a really good-looking shoe. I tried it in both the perforated (leather?) and the gray flannel and both looked great. One thing I like about it is that the white strip of rubber along the bottom is not as prominent as in some others of this style, and the "nose" of the shoe rises up a little bit from the white strip. I think it looks better than those where the nose is level with the white strip. I found the shoe to run slightly small. I usually wear an 8, and in these the 8.5 fit better. There is an easily-removable liner that gives _some_ arch support, but did not provide as much as I want. It could have been fine as is, but I bought an arch support insert from a running shoe store, cut it to match the liner provided, and I swapped them out. Perfect. You could probably do the same with a custom orthotic. I bought six different slip-on shoes to try, and this is the only pair I kept.

I think these shoes look great in person but the offer no support to your feet. I am an event planner and bought these specifically to wear onsite at events. I had no blisters but my feet were in so much pain by the end of the long day. I would not get these if you expect any function. They look good as an alternative to a sneaker but I would not buy them if you think you'll be on your feet for any extended period of time. My 2.5" heel booties were significantly better for my feet.

Easy to put on because of well placed elastic, supportive inside, refreshing profile but leopard material is cheaper looking than I expected.

Physical therapist approved! Great for falling arches, comfortable, lightweight.

These shoes have Dr. Scholl's gel insoles and are very comfortable. They accommodate bunions and neuromas. I wish they came in a more youthful style! The color is quite nice.

I love these shoes. They have been comfortable for all day wear and look stylish. I have slightly wide feet but these fit just fine and actually make my feet look narrower. I wear a 9 or 9.5 depending on the shoe and went with the 9.5 in these; they fit great. I also suffer from plantar fasciitis and these have been excellent comfortable casual shoes to go with most of my outfits.

I don’t know anything about the fit or comfort because I received the wrong shoe (similar, but different) and they were obviously used. I don’t mean it looks like someone tried them on. They were very used. So gross. The ones I received have a zipper so they are obviously a different model. The box was also dirty and ripped up. I’ve purchased so many shoes from Zappos and this is a first.

Didn't like the color and it felt uncomfortable.

So comfortable, I put them on right out of the box and wore all day without any discomfot! When i first put them on they seemed a bit too snug but within minutes felt just fine. And they are really cute, just what I was looking for. (size 6.5 Tan/Black Leopard)

These shoes fit and look great. Comfortable to wear all day long and I think the leopard print looks even nicer in person.

Really love the looks of these shoes. They are a little more stiff than my other Madison's but I love them. I was originally looking at another pair of animal print loafers that were double the price but I'm glad I got these instead.

Comfy and springy even after 15 hours on my feet.

These shoes are very comfortable and cute. I got the Merlot which is a rich purple red, and goes with nearly everything. I wanted a shoe that I could slip on easily and go (a mom shoe, if you will) and these fit the bill.

These shoes are so adorable and comfortable. The patent leather touch on the back makes it have a fun flair. The Dr. Scholl's team has really upped their design team - great job everyone! And thanks Zappos for offering them at an awesome price!

returned and reordered a half size larger...very comfortable ...happy with "animal"print...customer service with Zappos is A+

Just received these, and love the style. Unfortunately, they slip on my heels. Tried with a sock, still no good! So disappointed. I may try a half size smaller but won't be able to get them in time for vacation.

This shoe was longer and wider than I expected. Sad because it is a nice looking walking shoe.