Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Scout - Original Collection

I have been looking for literally years for shoes in this style that fit my feet. And I am not a hard fit. I tried slip-ons from Vans, Keds, Banana Republic, Gap, and Ann Taylor. All of them were either too tight in the toe box or too loose in the heel. As soon as I put these shoes on I knew that they were keepers. They are definitely the most stylish, and the insole is the most comfortable (eggcrate). The insole can also be removed if it is desired to replace. No break-in time required.

These sneakers were pretty comfortable. I bought them for a trip to Europe to look a little more stylish than my beat-up Nike Free's. The only issue that I had was that when it rained the black transferred onto my (white) socks. I didn't notice that my feet were wet, but the color transferred. Also, socks are necessary - the insole is slippery, and not removable. Regardless - even with heavy (8+ miles per day) walking, they were very comfortable.

In my hunt to find the prefect slip-on I've tried Scholl's Scout, Naturalizer Marianne, Ecco Aimee, Sofft Sommers, Skecher Vaso, and Vans Classic I had high expectations from Dr Scholl's and they didn't make the cut. I found them true to size for my 9.5, but not enough height in the toe-box, and, as other reviewer mentioned, too wide in heel. They kept slipping off but pressing my toes. Otherwise they are comfortable and have good support if they match your foot shape.

I love these shoes! I wanted cute slip ons in this exact style because I walk to/from walk and wanted to take these on a vacation with lots of walking around a city. These are perfect. They're SO comfortable and trendy looking, but have the comfort of a Dr. Scholl's shoe. The insole is removable but I kept it in - very supportive. The only issue is these definitely run a half size small. I'm always an 8.5 but had to exchange these for a 9. Otherwise, very happy!

Very cute shoe. i was concerned the shoe might feel small, based upon others' reviews. I ordered one 7.5 and one 8. Upon further thought, I think the shoe isn't so much small in size/length as it is in width. The 7.5 felt a bit narrow (and shallow) in the toe area but the 8 felt a little too loose. I followed the suggestion of another reviewer and tried wearing the 7.5 around the house on carpeting for a few days to see how it felt over time and if it would stretch at all. While it still feels a bit snug, it does feel as if it is stretching out and overall it is a comfortable/supportive sort of snug rather than anything that hurts my feet. Mix of the color with the suede lends this shoe to year round use and it is very cute with leggings or skinny jeans.

I ordered these shoes twice. It’s hard for me to find comfortable shoes bc I am a size 11 And on my feet ALL day. These are awesome. They look really cute and not too clunky on and I can stand and walk in them for hours. I just ordered them again bc my first pair had seen their day.

I bought these shoes for traveling. They looked very nice. Leather is beautiful and they have good support. I recommend going up half size as I wear size 9 but ordered 9.5 and that fit well. Worth the price!

I have a very narrow size 9 foot, ordered these in an 8 1/2 to make up for the width being a M. Fit perfect & will be wearing this spring & summer. I first tried DS Madison same type of shoe but even w 8 1/2 M width, it slipped off my heel. Returned for these and worked perfect.

I'm a fan. I've bought the Dr Scholl's Scout in both the taupe and the 'snakeskin' black. On here looking for another color. I guess I'll try the Madison ones next.. I have big feet for a woman and these are a nice option. Comfortable. I can wear them to work and they don't count as sneakers. But now I need to find same comfort in a shoe without the white band... definitely won't work with a tailored dress pant!

I was truly pleased with these shoes. I was concerned at first that they ran long and narrow. I decided to just wear them around the house to test. But hours later I forgot I had new shoes on and was off doing a lot in total comfort. Definitely will be a go to casual pair this season.

These shoes are cute and very comfortable. They have nice support. I have a very high instep and a wide foot and they fit wonderfully. Love them!!!

love this shoe! i tried on several other similar styles (vince, vans, etc) and this was the best fit and style. i love the slightly thinner sole and the off white. very comfortable and a good price. like many other reviewers said, i had to order a 1/2 size up.

This leather ran smaller than the black. I would order 1/2 size up.

This is the greatest most comfortable and stylish shoe out there. My feet swell easily especially when I travel so have to wear socks to prevent blistering. These are the only shoes I have ever worn that are comfortable all day long in the heat. Please keep making these. I keep waiting for more to be made. Don't change a thing!

Love these shoes! Super comfy & stylish. They fit true to size. They don't have great arch support but better than most. No sore feet after wearing them all day. A couple people have stopped me to ask what kind of shoes these are, & where I got them!

Ordered these for a trip to Europe. They were my go to shoe that were extremely comfortable. Stylish and well made. Only complaint is the toe box is a tad flat so my big toe couldn't wiggle until the leather stretched a bit.

I love these shoes. So comfortable and the cream colored leather makes them a nice winter white shoe versus some other brilliant white options.

I read the reviews on these and was so excited to wear them in Europe. Unfortunately, my experience was very different from the majority of the reviews. I found these shoes to be extremely painful and caused many blisters. I have slightly wide feet and high arch but felt they were appropriately broken in before my trip. WRONG! Blisters even with socks and the band-aid blister preventers. I also had the black staining issue someone else mentioned. The blisters weren't the worst though; my feet bones hurt! And even after the first day of walking, they looked terrible. The soles started disintegrating and the top became so wrinkly, they were very unattractive. Picture is at the end of day 1 in Paris :( After a few days I had to buy a new pair of shoes (nikes); i just couldn't take the pain.

Love these slip ons for the spring/summer/fall. I wear them with and without socks.

The shoes fit perfectly and walked over 2 miles in them without any issues. The shoes are fashionable and feel good.

From the minute I put this shoe on it felt great (and that never happens with my bony 10.5 size foot). I was looking for this style and also tried Vans Slip-on Core Classics, Vionic Demetra, and Gentle Souls Kenneth Cole Lowe elastic slip-on. This shoe (the Dr. Scholl's) had much better arch support and didn't rub around the ankle. It actually felt like it made my foot look smaller than the others and the white sole wasn't so pronounced from above (see comparison photo attached, Dr. Scholl's on left). I love Van's, but was looking for something I could dress up a bit more. Especially for the price, this shoe is a great option!

Love this shoe, the Scout. I own three pairs and live in them. I wish there was a black sueded option, but the leather is fine.