Customer Reviews Clarks Caslynn Shae

I have four pairs of Clarks Caslynn Lizzies. I adore them. I bought a color I don't even really like because I love the way those shoes feel so much! I can wear them all day and my feet don't hurt in the least. I wished I had purchased a pair in black last year so when these came out, I jumped at the chance to have my beloved Clarks in black. I am bit disappointed. The fit is different and they don't seem to have nearly the support the Lizzie's have. Also, they aren't as flattering to the foot as the Lizzie's. I'm not sure what Clark has done differently to make these less comfortable than the Lizzie's, but it's a noticeable difference. All that said, these are still more comfortable than the average equivalent. I'm obsessed with wedge heels and these are more comfortable than most.

I bought this shoe in size 8 and it fits fine. Everything is good, they are very comfortable. I even like the velcro but...the velcro isn't holding that well. It doesn't come off completely but it loosens almost as soon as I start walking in them and I have to stop and pull it tighter. I will keep the shoes and deal with it but just thought you might want to know. Maybe a stronger velcro? I am a very true 8 in Clarks shoes. The size is never a problem for me. Love them, most of the time!

Loved these but have to agree with others that commented on the velcro. Definitely returned these because of it. If you're not spot on the velcro adhesion strip, it looks bad...so whether you have to make it a little tighter than the norm or a little looser than the norm...it doesn't look right. They are extremely comfortable, however...so if you don't mind the look of a velcro strap...they hold the Clarks standard with their comfort.

I decided to keep these shoes because I needed a replacement for shoes that I had bought at Zappos a few years ago, and these came the closest to them. The style is a little clunky and I would prefer that the wedge not be as high, but they are amazingly comfortable and look good with pants.

I love these shoes. They are very comfortable and I was able to walk around everywhere in them. They wore a little on the sides of my feet, but after a short breaking-in period, it is all good.

I love this shoe! it looks great feels like it should be comfortable, but unfortunately it does not hit the right places on my foot. The strap is digging into one of my toes and my arch is in the wrong place. The foot bed matched my feet but I had to tighten the strap more than it should be tightened, leaving too much extra strap. I wish I could keep it.

Love these shoes! I do not normally wear heels, but these are not too high and have a nice cushion. At first they were a bit tight across the toes, even wearing a Wide, but after a few hours, were perfectly comfy. The only negative is the velcro buckle - kind of looks cheap in my opinion.

These shoes are really adorable and I wanted then to work, but the adjustable strap in the back still left too much room and I kept slipping out, but the smaller size was too small for my toes.

You really need a wider foot for these sandals. Slender feet will feel very loose and unstable: I literally would twist my foot every day in them. I wish these and more of Clarks cuter styles would come in Narrow! At least the wedges, where you need it the most for safety.

I loved these but they were slightly small. My foot hung off the back of the right shoe. I had to return. :(

These run way small. I wear a 7.5 in just about every brand and I could barely squeeze my foot into these. Very cute but will be returning them. I really appreciate Zappos awesome return policy.

Have been wearing Clarks forever and ordered my usual size but these run small. The straps are tight across the toes but the leather has some give so it's not unbearable. However, after a week of wear they have developed the most obnoxious squeaking when walking that it may be a deal breaker for keeping them.

Sexy shoe that makes my 11W feet look 3 sizes smaller and narrower. However, the shoe causes my feet and ankles to pitch inward, and that hurts after a short while in them. Unfortunately, I'll be returning them.

I bought my second pair of these shoes in black to replace one pair that had broken. The brass piece that holds the ankle strap on had broken and I loved these so much I immediately ordered a replacement pair toward the end of last summer. Today is the first day that I have worn the new pair to work and the exact same thing happened. Now, I have spent more on a pair of shoes that are trash. I probably have not worn them more than a dozen times. This is sad because I love these shoes, they are comfortable to wear and walk in all day and I bought them in other colors as well. To say that I am disappointed is a understatement. I expect so much better from Clarks.

Very cute and go with almost anything! They seemed comfy at first but they don't hold the heel in securely. They're also too wide in the front and on top of that they stretched out even more so the foot always slides forward. They're totally unstable and if the ground is even slightly uneven you twist your foot. Had to take them out of rotation.

I own a lot of pairs of Clarks and ordered these in my usual size but had to return them for 1/2 size larger. The fit is tight, but the shoe is comfortable. Even so, I am ready to take them off by the end of the day because of the fit. Not sure a larger size would have helped. I hope they will eventually loosen up! I had to remember how to walk in platforms!

I bought these sandals two years ago. After wearing them a lot last summer, (and hoping to wear them this summer), they stink so badly, I cannot even get the smell out. The footbed is not leather and absorbs foot order like there is no tomorrow. I scrubbed with Tide and I still cannot make them that much better. Please note that I generally have pretty nice smelling feet, but you put them in a synthetic foot bed and it is not so pretty. Just a heads up. Many shoe manufacturers who used to use all leather, have now gone to the dark side and are using materials that do not have the same properties as leather. They may say it is soft, and Clarks even sells its own footbed cleaner, but you should not have to scrub the footbed of such an expensive pair of sandals.

Just purchased this is tan. I really like the shoe, but it's uncomfortably tight and there is no size 10 1/2 to move up to. Going to try a shoe stretcher to see if I can make it work for me.

Very cute shoe and comfortable for summer at the office, but way too small. My heel was hanging off the back and the velcro was exposed, not a good look. I am ordering half a size up and hoping for the best since I do like the color of the light tan.

I love how these look, but they are so, so tight! I usually wear a 9.5 or 10, bought the 10 and can barely get my feet in them! Sending them back...so sad!

I have had these shoes for a couple of years. They are very comfortable but very unstable. The upper strap support is too giving and the sole at the heel is too narrow to stabilize the shoe. I only wear them if I am going to be sitting most of the time.

I have a wide foot and can fit into most 11W but not these - not long enough nor wide enough. Too bad. I LOVE THEM. I would order a larger size but nothing is available. Boo!

I ordered my normal size, 9W, and found this shoe to be very loose. The back strap needs elastic or should be tighter to provide a snug fit. The strap as seen in the picture is worthless in my opinion. The shoes were flopping off of my feet when I tried to walk. I would recommend sizing down but I'm not certain that would fix the problem. This shoe fits very similar to Crocs. The shoe did arrive promptly, thank you Zappos.

SO NARROW!!! Ridiculously narrow. Unreasonably narrow. I usually have no problems fitting in a 7.5 women's shoe. I ordered these in a 7.5 regular and couldn't even get them my toes through the straps. Tried an 8 regular and still couldn't get them on! Out of desperation, I ordered an 8 wide and while I can get them on, they are so tight that they're actually cutting off circulation to my feet. I have never had this problem with any other Clarks shoe! I am super disappointed because they are adorable and the footbed is very comfortable - either that or my feet have gone numb.

These shoes are very dangerous! I have worn heels for YEARS & much higher than these, including wedges. I love the comfort of this shoe and that they are a good height. BUT, on numerous occasions the shoe just topples over without warning. I fell yesterday when it did it again. I was not in a hurry and was just casually walking. The faulty design of this shoe is going to seriously injure people. The design needs to be fixed ASAP! I am returning mine!