Customer Reviews Bed Stu Judgement

Great quality. I usually size up half sz for heels and I have wider feet, so I was nervous it wouldnt be big enough but they fit perfect. Very comfy.

Ordered normal size but it was too small. Hurt my feet.

Beautiful boots! Fit perfectly!

I love these boots! They are my 5th pair of Bed Stu since being introduced to this company 2 years ago. After looking through the comments, I chose to order my normal size, 8.5 bc I'm really in between an 8 and 8.5. The size was perfect. I have worn them just a few times, they look great and are beginning to feel great! I've got my eye on several more pair of Bed Stu, I may soon have my closet filled :)

This pair of boots has something sticking up from underneath that hurts my foot. A cobbler nail perhaps? I have this pair in brown and loved them but this black pair is not so good. Kind of bummed because they were expensive.

I love the boots!! The color is gorgeous. They look amazing! They are a little snug, but the leather will relax with wear. I went up a half a size based on reviews.

I tried the shoes in a store in my area. They only had size 8.5 I generally fit a size 8. The 8.5 was very tight- I could hardly stand in it therefore I was advised to buy a size bigger so I had to go on line and I ordered the size 9. Ive worn it about 5 times and its already flapping when I walk in it. I want to return it because the 9 is too big but 8.5 is too tight. Help

Loving everything about these boots!

True to size, very comfirtable and as always expected from Bedstu, BEAUTIFUL, impeccably hand crafted.

These boots are so comfortable right from the beginning. The color has just the right amount of distress and style is modern yet classic and they will never go out of style. Really in love with these. I want the brown ones now : ).

I love these vintage looking boots. Very comfortable when first putting them on, but I have not worn them out and about yet. I did size up a 1/2 size as recommended, and they fit great with my normal socks.

Size up and super comfortable! The laces done wrap around the shoe like in the picture shown. They feel solid, like I wont slip in the rain. They are very comfortable. I highly recommend them and cannot wait for black to come back in stock! If youre questioning it, its worth it. Im typically a 10/41 and I ordered an 11. The 11 had room for thin or thick socks but wasnt too big. Overall, perfect and sturdy.

Im so happy with this purchase! I absolutely love my Judgment boots. At first, I thought they were too small. Everyone said to size up, but the next size up was continually out of stock. I am a 7.5 or 8; most often a size 8. I ordered the size 8 and it did feel snug at first, especially on my left foot. There was a breaking in period, but by the third wear, the sizing felt perfect. The color is rich and beautiful. The style reminds me of Grandmas boots from old movies, only better. I love the comfort and non-slippery soles. This wont be my last pair!

I love my boots and they fit perfectly. I listened to the reviews and went up a size I usually wear an 8.5 and purchased 9.5.

Shoe definitely runs small. I am usually a size 6.5 and sized up to a 7 which was waaaaay more comfy (I bought the 6.5 originally and returned them for the 7). Each show is unique, the 6.5 was fairly solid blue (I got the teal) but the 7 looked slightly more distressed so theyre definitely all unique in their own way. A HUGE STEP UP FROM THE FAST FASHION SINGLE SEASON BOOTS IVE BOUGHT IN THE PAST!!! I call these my first big girl purchase lol

Gorgeous shoes! They smell so nice out of the box and are honestly a huge step up from the fast fashion cheap boots Ive worn historically. I call these my first pair of big girl boots lol will buy more again as my budget allows :rofl:

These boots are beautiful, I purchased the the NEW TEAl color (something different) and it met my expectations. For the sizing I had my fingers crossed because I had read all the reviews after I placed the order. I went with my size 8 for boots am normally a 7 1/2. I tried them with short thick socks and they had the snug I expected and tried with thinner ones and they were perfect. I already know that they will stretch with wear

I ordered the Judgement boot in Black Rustic, size 10. I was a little reluctant only because I'm not great at walking in anything that has a heel. BUT I will tell you this, once you get these bad boys on, it's over for ya! I literally want every color Bedstu has in these boots!! Oh my goodness, the compliments I receive when wearing these, makes me smile!! I will purchase these again, but this time it will be Tan Rustic. Can not get enough of these lovelies!! The craftsmanship and the red bottoms... YESSSS!! Gives me life. Thank You, Bedstu for being amazing!

I have 5 pairs of Bed Stu Boots: the quality is phenomenal & this style is SO versatile! The price = Quality & Classic Style. The sizing 'is off' : I'm guessing because they are handmade? Make sure to measure feet IF ordering online. These (I have Tan Rustic) look good w/ jeans, dresses, & even shorts: IOW--They work well w/ literally everything! I have this pair for 3 years & they continue to be in LIKE NEW condition! Can you tell I have a true love relationship with Bed Stu?!

First off - these boots are absolutely stunning!! They match literally anything and everything and have such a beautiful finish. The leather is super soft and they're comfortable right out of the box and have only gotten better with wear. I definitely recommend going up atleast a half size! I wear 8 in bedstu typically, but I went up to 8.5. ('d probably be even happier in a 9 tbh).

I got my Judgement boots in Teak Taupe Rustic just 3 days ago. I did go a half size up as advised and they fit perfect. The leather is so soft and the color is beautiful. I've been eyeing these for a while and finally did it. I'm so glad I did. They are insanely cute and comfortable. These boots are an amazing product. I can wear them with anything. They are high quality boots and can be worn year round. Customer service at Bed Stu is also great. I highly recommend these boots to anyone.

I bought these in the Tan Rustic and Graphito Rustic colors. I love them both. I wish I had known about them back when the merlot color was available because I would have purchased them as well. The leather smells amazing and they are so soft. I did go half a size up and that was perfect for me. They were still snug but I prefer that type of fit. Id only worn them around the house once and I tried them on again a few days later and they had already stretched from the one time I tried them on. Im glad I didnt go a full size bigger.

I LOVE these boots. They match almost everything, and are wicked comfortable despite having a moderate heel. I get complimented every time I wear these out, 1000% recommend! I wear an 8/8.5 in BED|ST boots, and an 8.5 was a great fit for me.

I love these boots! Purchased a 9 I am usually a 8.5 but I figured out that the higher the heel its better to half size up. I cant wait for more colors to come in!