Customer Reviews Calvin Klein Gayle Pump

Really fun work heel. I needed a gray/silver heel and I like the balance between fancy but not too bold for work. I am caught between a size 9.5 and 10 normally and I have other Calvin Klein heels that I wear in a size 10. However I tried both sizes and went with a 9.5.

These fit perfectly in my regular size (8 medium) and were exactly what I was needing to wear with an antique rose velvet dress as a wedding guest at a recent fall wedding in the Hamptons. They were also supremely comfy and I wore them all night - including plenty of time on the dance floor - with absolutely zero issues. Totally a great shoe and the perfect height too. I want to buy them in every color now, and I might do just that! The price is well worth it and reasonable.

Beautiful shoes. A good “high heel” height, not stilettos but not a mid heel either. The cut is just high enough so there is no camel toe effect across your feet. The point is the shoe is a little severe for my taste but it is just as it looks in the picture so I can’t deduct for that. Still, even with my bigger size 9 foot, it doesn’t make my foot look horribly long because of the heel height. Already looking to get another color!

I adore these heels!!! This is the ONLY pair of heels higher than 2 inches I've been able to wear since my early 20s!! Obviously they're not going to be comfortable if you're standing all day long or walking long distances, but these are better than any other pointed-toe heel I've tried, including another brand that is MADE for comfort! If they made these in every color I would need an entire room for my new CK shoe collection!

Love them so much I have every color in the patent

These are a great staple shoe for the collection. The heel height is perfect and the style is classic. They are nude, but they are a gray nude and not a tan nude. Not an issue, just an observation. I ordered a half size larger than my normal size 7 as they are pointed and they fit perfectly. I have a medium width foot and I found these true to width. My son's girlfriend tried them on her narrow foot and they were too wide for her. I also ordered the Michael Kors Flex Mid Heel which is almost the identical shoe in all respects except it is a tan nude. The Calvins had a slightly nicer side profile and heel placement (the MK heel was further under the shoe in appearance) These also have a little toe cleavage which I like, but I know is a deal breaker for others. I wore them to a wedding for several hours standing, walking and sitting and they were fine comfort-wise (no blisters), but I was happy to remove at the end of the night.

I ordered these shoes for my girlfriend and she loved them so much, that she asked me to order another pair for "back up" so she will have them after these wear out. "She absolutely loved the shoes!" Unfortunately, they only come in black with the lacquered finish. If I could buy them in grey and other colors with the "Lacquered finish" I would be ordering them in other colors. The shoes fit perfectly, with the 3" heel (which is nice) but a 2 3/4 inch heel would make the shoes absolutely perfect.

I love the style of the shoe! I have it in 7 different colors. I have bought the black over again three times!

I ordered 3 pairs and each fit differently. One fit perfectly and one was too tight. The last pair was in between. I do like the style of the shoe and the heel height is perfect for office wear.

I reordered this shoe since I loved my old pair but these do not fit the same and the quality seems worse. While they look great, the toe is way tighter now and the inside is already wearing away near the toe after a dozen wears or so.

Normally, I wear a 5 or 5.5 shoe. These were about a half size too big. Perhaps they run a bit large. Basically, I could not keep them on my feet when I tried them on. They are pretty shoes, though.

Size is running half size small. My daughter who is a true size 8, kept the 7 1/2. The 8 ran big. Ordered same shoe in white elsewhere and had the same issue, so this particular shoe is running a half size big.

These run small and are a little shinier than I expected. Got something I prefer from Sam Edelman.

I wanted to love these shoes. I have flat feet was looking for a comfortable 3 inch pair of navy heels and I was hoping these were it. My biggest issue with this shoe is that the leather just isn’t comfortable or soft. It’s very stiff leather. While I have no problem on the heel or the height of the heel, the leather makes it an uncomfortably shoe. It really is a beautiful shoe (and the color is great) and I get a lot of compliments but I’m still looking for that perfect navy heel.

material is nice, but as a lady with wide feet these definitely cut into the tops of my feet despite me ordering the wide size.

I have been using this shoes for over 4 years and lately they are getting narrower and narrower. They are not comfortable.

Omg these are one of favs! I have them four different colors . They are smart and transition from the office to after 5 beautifully…BUT who needs a shoe with sole that’s crumbles ??? Yikes ! If you are good with this then it’s a fab shoe if not then don’t buy this beauty of a shoe … so sad:(

I wear a 7.5, and ordered that size first but it was way too small. I exchanged for an 8, because I loved how they looked, but was still too uncomfortable to keep. I wear heels almost everyday, and there was no way I could even make it out of the house in these, let alone work a full day in them! So sad, because they were so pretty..

It is a beautiful looking shoe, but quite small and narrow, requiring at least a half to full size up and wider width. Also just hits bone in foot.

I was very surprised at how cheap these look for CK heels, the low quality is apparent as soon as you take them out of the box. I needed a simple pair of pumps for work and unfortunately these are also too tight.

I have been purchasing these same shose for years the same size and style and they were very comfortable to wear all day every day. The last one I purchased is not comfortable at all it’s very tight and it hurts my feet. I can’t wear them and work all day at all. Something had changed they felt very uncomfortable.

Felt much larger than a 5, color is darker than pictured (and duller), and the seal at the bottom where the plastic outside meets the sole wasn't properly done/peeling and exposed the exterior as truly just bad plastic.

Too small and too narrow

These run very narrow through the toes. They hurt just trying them on. I can't imagine wearing them anywhere. They are beautiful and a great color. The material is very stiff and doesn't seem like it will stretch over time.

I normally wear an 8N so I wasn't sure what I would need in these (they are higher than I normally wear). An 8M was fine, probably because the toe area wasn't too high up my foot. The color has a textured feel, making it perfect for an embroidered dress I have. It looks like it matches the thread perfectly, from color to texture.