Customer Reviews Comfortiva Tobago - Soft Spots

I failed to consider earlier reviews about this shoe running small. It does. I am impressed with the quality of workmanship and materials. A great buy. But I am also concerned about the interior chafing the tops of my toes and for that reason will not be reordering. Very sad.

I bought this same style many years ago in the same size and width. When they finally wore out I bought this pair, but these are too short and my toes are jammed against the front while my heel is right on the back of the shoe. Also, I wear narrow but these shoes feel too tight. I'm sure the width would stretch out and be fine after awhile but the length is what concerns me. I will be returning them. I would get a half size bigger but now they are out of stock.

I ordered a double wide. This shoe is NOT even a wide. It’s more like a Narrow. I tried to look at the label inside the shoe to confirm the width, but there was none. Either they sent the wrong size, or this is a joke. Never had I had a problem like this with Zappos.

I really like these shoes. They're woven leather, which will stretch out pretty quickly, so I think that's why some people are saying they're too small when they arrive. They need to be on the small side at first! I ordered my usual size and the shoes fit me well, both in the length and the width. They're slightly snug right now (brand new), but I got a pair a few summers back and they very quickly stretched to fit my feet perfectly with wear. I really love this style. They look great on, and they go with a lot of different styles of clothing. They don't pinch, rub, or give me any blisters. I could put them on right out of the box with no problem. I technically have medium-width feet, but they're definitely on the wide side of medium. I also have very high arches. Many shoes are painful for me to try to cram into, but these shoes aren't like that at all. Very easy to get on and off too. I don't have to unbuckle them, I just pull them on and pull them off with the buckle fastened. I bought a pair of these shoes a few summers ago. My only complaint with them is that on each shoe one of the woven leather strips pulled out and became loose, but that was after I had worn the shoes for a couple of year. The leather strips are just glued in, not sewn down, so they can come loose over time. But I had bought the natural color that first time, which is a great color for summer, but by the time the leather strips pulled out the leather was looking a little dingy and dirty, so I probably would have thrown them out soon anyway. I got the rust color this time in the hopes that the darker color won't look dirty over time.

I love this sandal and I'm glad I bought it. A few words of advice: I read other reviews that stated this shoe runs a big small, so although I am usually a size 6-1/2 US, I ordered a size 7. The fit is perfect. I also read that it runs narrow, so initially I ordered it in a Wide. It was far too wide, so I exchanged that pair for a medium or standard width, and that fits just fine. My only complaint is that as I hike somewhat long distances several times per week, the ball of each foot is usually a bit sore or fatigued, and although these are cushioned in that area, However, I still feel the ache. I suspect most people would find this shoe quite comfortable.

Great shoe. Left foot smaller than right so buckle makes for good fit for both. Padded footbed is also comfortable. I bought all colors.

I ordered size 9 to replace the 8.5 that were too small. I have never before needed to order a half size up! The photo shows the sandal next to my size 8.5 SAS loafer for comparison - it's a bit shorter. I can't wear open-toed sandals at work, and these are my best option. Huaraches usually get too wide after a few months, and these fit just right on Day 1, but I think they'll be my go-to sandals for the summer.

Very cute show. Tan was true to on line. Had nice soft footbed. But, the toe was awfully short and pressed down on my toes which I've never had happen before. I also believe that it could take a while to break in unless you were to wear them with a footie a few days first. Because I have difficult feet to find a good shoe home, this will probably be one of my last tries on a cute shoe. Looks like I'm destined to ugly shoes which are too wide in the heel and will accept my orthotics of which I've already tried a hundred of. Thank you Zappos for putting up with me.

Very cute huarache style with more arch support and footbed comfort than you can usually expect. Runs narrow, though. I first ordered medium width (B), which is what I normally wear. Those felt too tight, and I knew I couldn't spend a day on them comfortably. So I sent them back and got the widest width (EE). Those have been great. I probably could have gotten the width between B and EE, but I was able to wear them all day without an issue.

This shoe runs smaller than marked. I ordered a half size bigger and also widest size available and am glad I did because the shoe fits perfectly. It is a very comfortable shoe!

I have terrible feet very hard to find a pair that I can wear. When I first tried these on I thought they weren't going to work. I wore them a little while longer and they are going to be just fine. I really like them very attractive and summery. I have really wide feet so if you do these should work. Better get soon they always run out of wide shoes. Love Zappos

Very cute shoes, ordered these as well as the Trinidad style. These definitely ran on the small side, but the biggest issue was the strap design on top rubbed against the skin on the top of my foot. The Trinidad straps lay flat and the shoes fit better, so that was the pair I kept. For comparison, I ordered the Tobago in 9.5 M and the Trinidad in 9 M.

Very soft and very comfortable...they are so beautiful...leather so soft and you will want a pair in every color. Great price as well. Comfort and style!

I love the look of these sandals, but the heel strap would not stay up on my heel. I feel it is a design flaw. I am going to return them, and search for a different style.

Loved the look of these sandals. The fit was fine for my extra wide feet, but the straps were very uncomfortable at a few places on my feet.

They are leather and fit tight so I have been wearing around the house to break them in. Not unusual for that type of shoes. Really like them and the color is perfect.

I have triangular feet (wide at the base of the toes, narrow at the heel). These fit comfortably right out of the box. I bought a size 6 and the European size was given at 36.5.

this is my 3rd pair and love them

Super comfy sandal. I have wide feet and a tender L foot due to recent surgery. Sandals are soft and also provide support. Leather breathes and stretches to fit.

I listened to the other reviews and ordered a 1/2 size larger than normal. I'm glad I did! They are still a bit snug but being leather, I think they will stretch to a comfort fit. Quality looks good and the price was reasonable.

I’m glad I read the other reviews before I ordered. I ordered a half size larger and wide instead of medium and they fit well.

Love these shoes...really cute! I have a very wide foot so I ordered a wide and the width was fine. As others have mentioned, they run small (should have listened to them!) so I have returned my regular size for a half size larger.

I have very wide feet and have a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable for me. After reading the reviews I ordered the extra wide one half size larger than usual. They arrived yesterday and are both too long and too wide! I love the look of the shoe so I will return them for my regular size in a regular width.

Well fitting shoe and so much better constructed than most "huarache" styled shoe/sandals. Very comfortable soles. Ordered a Double Wide, which means I come down a full size than when I buy a my usual wide only. AM so much happier and far more comfortable with Double Wides! So nice many shoe makers are now making double wides in so many shoes styles. My feet are so thankful!