Customer Reviews VIONIC Judith Flat Mary Jane

These are really cute shoes! I wear an 8 in this brand, bought a 9 since they run small, returned them, and am waiting for a pair in 9½. But they are very cute, and provide great arch support.

When I tried this shoe on in a store I knew that it was really comfortable and that I wanted a pair. But the Vionic shoe you sent me had a place that sticks out on the inside which is very uncomfortable. I am disappointed!

They run really small and narrow. I have a narrow foot so they usually are wide on me but this one is tight across and too short. I usually wear a 6 1/2. Too bad because they are really cute.

I love this shoe; I am desperately looking for a comfortable Mary Jane to wear w skirts and dress pants, particularly in the Fall and Spring. I am having much failure. This shoe is great on the arch and heel but the instep or vamp is so low it hurts my feet pressing on the ball joint of my big toes - on both feet. I have a bunion on one but not the other so I know it's not my feet this time, per se. So gravely disappointed. They will be shipped back. :(

I bought these shoes in beige color to wear with both skirts and pants. My major motivation was to have Orthaheel footbed since I have problems with middle/rear foot. I cannot easily change shoes since I wear Orthaheel inserts. This shoe fits my rounded foot well with ample room for toes. They look somewhat wide but the fit is snug. My only complaint is the heel: I wish it is a little bit higher and deeper to stabilize the foot as Orthaheel promises. Also the stitch above the front foot is a little stiff and hurts during initial wear. The higher heel would help to avoid this problem.

Very cute and comfortable shoe. Definitely runs small. I usually fit a 7 wide or 7.5 medium and I needed an 8 medium in this style.

I had ordered these really cute shoes a full size larger based on many reviews about how they run small. I thought about exchanging them for a full size and a half larger, but was doubtful that they would fit across the largest joints of the toes and still fit everywhere else. If you have a narrow or narrow medium foot, these will be ok, however even the length runs short, so you may have to do a lot of exchanging before you can get it right. They are beautiful shoes, so if you have the time, it's worth trying to get them right.

I loved the look of these shoes. I bought a size 8 even though I usually take a 7. It took me a while to break them in, they were tight at the band that crosses over the top of your foot. Now that I have broken them in they are comfortable and hold my arches in place. Wish the band was just a little bit longer.

This shoe let my foot pronate a lot. The arch support just didn't do the job. The toes were comfortable though a bit snug. I needed a half size larger, If it were offered in a wider width that would be good for bunions and pronating ankles. I am past 65 and need foot support.

Following the advice of others who reviewed this shoe, I ordered a full size larger. The length just fit, but then (of course) the heel was sloppy. Also, the right shoe was damaged to the right of the toe-box. I've ordered many Orthaheel brand shoes - but have found that since "Vionic" is now their 'mother ship', the quality is not (not) what it used to be, nor is the sizing reliable. I have no idea what happened on a corporate level with the original Orthaheel brand, but whomever is currently running their quality assurance is sleeping on the job, or in a full coma.

I have a lot of Vionic/Orthaheel shoes (at least 10 pair) and really wanted to love these. I ordered 1/2 size larger and they were still way too short. They seem to run wider than most of my other Vionics. The last did not seem to fit as my other Vionics do, so I had to return them.

I have Orthaheel Vionic sandals that fit true to size. These were way smaller. I could barely get my foot in the shoe. This style runs very small.