Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I ordered up to a 9.5 (normal sneaker is a 9), that was probably a big enough increase, but as soon as I put my foot in, my thought was it really needs an insert. Not comfortable on the footbed. Very disappointed because as soon as they came out of the box my thought was "They are so cute for a snow boot, I really hope they work out." Just didn't find them comfy and I walk a lot in snow boots. Usually love Columbia.

A snow boot that is available in ladies size 5.5 WIDE and actually fits true to size, including around the leg. My feet are so happy. And the boots are actually a reasonable style and color. The only thing I would change about the boots is that I wish the snow gusset between the leg and tongue extended all the way up to the top of the boot instead of only half way up.

These boots do not keep my feet as warm as I had hoped. I've ordered some wool boot liners and hope that will do the trick.

This boot feels like it would be perfect on an arctic or Scandinavian vacation! I would like more arch support though.

I was most interested in traction. But have not been able to test that yet

The wide size didn't feel any wider than the normal sizing so had to return. They are super cute but just not comfortable and didn't fit well.

They would have been super comfy except for there was a spot that rubbed on my ankle bones so had to return.

I wear a 9M or 9W depending on the shoe. I ordered these boots in a 9 1/2 W so I could wear heavy socks. They fit, but I thought they would feel bigger than they do. The suede around the left ankle is very stiff and is irritating to my ankle. The laces are silky and I think they will come untied easily. I’ll buy some lace locks. I’m hoping that the suede will soften up because other than that they are very comfortable. Easy on and off.

My daughter loved these, but fit was 1/2 size too small. Exchanged size 6 for 6.5 and fit was perfect.

Brought these to get ready for winter. Ordered a size 9 wear an 8.5 (half size bigger to accommodate for wearing thick socks). They fit like an 8.5 and I didn’t try them on with thick socks. Not sure if they will loosen up once the insulation has molded into the boot.

I initially ordered a 1/2 size up, but changed them to my normal size (10). Soft inside and enough room for socks.

These boots are really cute!! I bounce between a 6.5 and 7 I shoes. I got the 6.5 and should have got the 7. I wore them a good bit the first week I got them (went skiing) and they were pretty comfortable. My toes still did get a bit cold. I’m always cold though!!

I normally do not wear a wide width. However, I returned the first pair I ordered to exchange for a wide width, and even the wide was too narrow in toe bed. I have a very slight bunion, and it put pressure on that area. I had to return because I knew it would be uncomfortable in the long run. Too bad, as it is a cute boot.

I love the boots. I got compliments the first time I wore them. I purposely picked wide width for extra room for thick socks. I am so glad I've purchased these fabulous boots.

My first pair was very comfortable but not waterproof so I bought a second pair hoping to exchange. The second pair was too tight/uncomfortable so I returned them chosing comfort over waterproofness. I am sorry I can't get both comfort and the waterproofness advertised, but don't want to waste time ordering a third pair!

Cute boot but too small.

I wore these boots in the snow for a week and liked everything about them... comfort, width, warmth, flexibility, weight, and style. Then yesterday I wore them on my morning walk in heavy rain. They are definitely NOT waterproof! My socks got very wet. Either my pair is defective or the "waterproof" label refers to the soles and lower edges, not the tops that encounter rain. (That's not what "waterproof" means to me!) I'll probably keep them because I have Raynauds and they keep my toes from turning white and getting numb. And, in light rain my socks have stayed dry. Is there's a waterproofing spray I could use on the fabric tops.

These are cute boots, and I had really hoped they'd work out. Unfortunately, although the overall size was fine, the bottom laces pressed on my big toe knuckle, and I knew they'd have to go back.

The size and fit were spot on. True to size and easy to get on and off. They are warm and comfortable without being too heavy. I love these boots!

Really love these boots! They fit perfectly and the first time I wore them, I stood in a pile of snow in 12* weather. My feet stayed dry and toasty warm.