Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Does not look like the picture at all. I was excited to get something a little different than brown on brown. Might return.

These boots were definitely not wide but I probably could have tolerated them with thin socks. The problem is that there is a rigid plastic piece in the back of the boot that dug into my heel and hurt after walking around in them for too long. I just tested them around the house so I'm sure it would have been unbearable after a whole day out and about. I tried exchanging them but had the same problem. They're very cute so I'm sad to have to send them back.

The boots are not totally waterproof; foot of boot permitted moisture to my socks. The "insulation" is extremely bad; wore boots in 30 degrees C and toes very cold.

Stiff, cheaply made, very thin material and badly insulated. Zero arch support. Hefty, inflexible sole. Worst snow boots I've ever tried on.

Fit snd size was fine. The shoe bed was extremely uncomfortable!

Very uncomfortable, footbed! Hard as rock!

Really a bummer as these were extraordinarily narrow even though they were marketed as wide width. Very uncomfortable.

These boots are super stiff and small-feeling to me. I have to return them because they are so uncomfortable. I am surprised because I usually love Columbia boots. I am bummed because the style is super cute. I wish these worked for me. I am usually a 6.5, but they are really tight.

Sadly, the boot felt half a size too small and the medium was very narrow across the mid-foot. They felt so uncomfortable, I couldn’t even tell if the arch might have been right or not. There is no way I can stand or contemplate walking in them and will return them. They were out of the wide width and I wouldn’t know whether getting a W would fix the half size too small feeling as well. Too much hassle to keep ordering and returning till it’s a good fit. On a bright note, they are pretty!

Felt like cardboard inside. No padding at all. Had to return them. They looked cute.

No arch support. Killed my feet after wearing for a couple hours.

The shoes are so uncomfortable! There is a seam on top by the shoelaces and when you put the shoes on it rubs on your foot. It is impossible to walk in these because of the hard seam inside. Too bad. Had to return them.

I absolutely love this boot. Sizing was perfect, design cute and very warm. In fact I loved them so much I bought a second pair. in another color on another website, because Zappos did not have it in my size. Ill be prepared for winter wonderland vacation in Vermont.

I ordered 8W, fit like 7N. Very disappointed. Style was cute, although didn't have a dark rasberry shade.

Even if this boot had been available in my D width (I tried the C width), I doubt it would've fit. It was so stiff over the instep that it hurt my foo. Disappointing because it is really cute style-wise.