Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I ordered these because I have a pair in black that I love. I ordered a 91/2 wide which is my usual size and they were extremely tight. They didn't fit like all my other Columbia wide with boots. I loved the color, price and the look of the boot but unfortunately they went back.

It's hard for me to review these boots. The ran probably 2 sizes too big. I didn't get to wear them outside. They were clearly a great quality and super comfortable. I read reviews before I purchased, and no one mentioned that they ran big. I don't know if I got a weird post. I was disappointed though because they looked and felt perfect.

Not a fan! While these boots are super comfortable. The Omni grip soles have let me down too many times! At first I thought it was because my shoes needed to be replaced so I purchased another pair but I had the same result of falling in them, my newest pair a couple of times. The sole showing signs of wear much sooner than my other Columbia boots that I wear fair more frequently! If you are purchasing these for fashion and comfort you will love them and I highly recommend them! If you are purchasing them for safety, keep looking! They don't live up to the usual Omni grip status of most Columbia shoes.

Nice looking boot, however I found this style of boot to run small in the 8 1/2 woman's. Sent it back and repurchased the size 9 which Felt like a normal 9 so it was too large. Sent it back. The boot did not feel comfortable like my many other Columbia boots. Sad to I'm disappointed in this boot.

Was out on the ice for a couple hours on a 20 degree day and my toes were cold. Wore wool socks. Don't think they'd stand up to an actual cold day. They are cute and I didn't have and issue with the fit. Just expected them to be much warmer.

This is a nice boot made with quality materials. But it was not a true wide. I ordered a size US 9.5D (wide) and measured the insole width at 3.75" and the girth at about 8.5". In general (in every size chart I've seen), that size should be over 4" wide. Manufactures will claim they make up for a small insole with more material for the girth, or that you can loosen the laces, but this is not sufficient for a healthy fit. I would love this boot if it were actually made to fit wide feet.

The boot is advertised to be warm in - 32 degrees C. I wore these boots in a barn; temps about 40 degrees C and my toes froze

Not warm enough for Michigan winters, minimal cushion, feet hurt. These are fashion winter boots and look great, not meant for cold weather and walking in snow for longer that from door to car.

Nice looking shoe, but doesn't fit well on the foot.