Customer Reviews Steve Madden Stecy Stiletto Sandal

Super cute. Entirely too narrow.

This is straight for looks...a cheap shoe. The ankle strap drove me crazy. It was a little tight.....so tooo short. Not made sturdy slides around....the holes are not stamped all the way thru so you need too hands to buckle the shoe....When I am getting dress and have a dress on I dont want to .BREAK A SWEAT TO BUCKLE THE SHOE..& AND WRINKLE MY DRESS......The fact that I still think about this everytime I get any image of this shoe or similar., ....gives my flashbacks.....and bothers me enough to write this long review should be enough for you to under stand.... The shoes is defintely not worth the 89.00 price point ...more like a 39.99 price if that......FOR ME ANYTHING THAT HURTS MY FEET IS NOT DEFINITE NO GO.

The strap across the toes is way too thin. I have very narrow feet (like oddly slim and narrow) and I could hardly get my toes under the toe strap because it was also so tight! My first attempt to walk in these was so uncomfortable, they didn’t hold my feet in whatsoever. I returned and found a very similar pair for $30 at Kohls (Apt 9 brand) which had just a bit wider of a toe strap, which was also better (a tad more loose) in fitting your toes under as well, and they worked out perfectly!

These shoes are so incredible tight. I have a fairly narrow foot and could barely get it through the strap.

These are some of the most uncomfortable heels I've ever bought. The straps are so tight! I've tried everything to stretch them out and even after trying to wear them over a few months they are still uncomfortable. I can only wear them sparingly unfortunately.

Not sure what happened with these, but my usual size (7.5) was way, way too small. I don't know that even a half size larger would fit. I could squeeze my foot into the shoe itself, but there was not way the ankle strap was going to buckle and actually hit and went around my upper foot rather than above that little bone on the side of the ankle. Really weird. I'm going to try a larger size, but I'll also order a back-up in a different style, just in case.

These were awful on me. The strap across the toes hit at a very odd spot and was very tight and uncomfortable. These will be going back. Ordered Aldo Fiolla in bone instead and adore those!

PAINFUL, LEFT BLISTERS. based on other's reviews, I ordered a (WIDE). I've never ordered a W before, but my 6.5 foot is not considered narrow by any means. the Wide fit was absolutely necessary. I have a huge blister on my heel from the back piece near the strap scraping with every step. totally disappointed with this shoe's comfort. I bought a food pad as well, and it still made the ball of my foot sore after a few hours

Way too narrow and I don't have a wide foot I could not even get my toes into the front strap. Returning

These shoes were exactly the style I was looking for and the wide size fit my feet perfectly. However they were very painful and not well padded. When I first tried them on out of the box, I could immediately feel the stiletto heel through the shoe. When I wore these at a wedding, the balls of my feet were quickly in pain even though I had added a silicone padding. By the reception time, I could barely stand in these shoes due to pain. The height of the shoe is probably too high given the lack of padding at the ball of the feet.

I've been looking for a shoe like this for awhile now and decided to try this one. It's a very cute shoe but way too narrow. I have a 8M foot but my feet hung way over the sides of this shoe. Sadly, I had to return these.

These shoes are lovely and would be good for someone with a very narrow foot. My feet are normal width and I could barely get my toes under the strap. I ordered a 6.5 like I wear in all other steve madden shoes. They were so painful that I couldn't even walk around my bedroom in them. Maybe a size up would help the toe, but I think would cause problems on the ankle. I sent them back and am in the search for a different brand of strappy shoes.

The heel height and the structure of the shoe actually made my narrow feet look wide. My feet hurt in the 3 minutes I had them on. The ankle strap seemed misplaced...there was no way to get it right and be able to walk. Gorgeous and yet highly uncomfortable. Sadly, had to go back.

I am normally a solid 8.5 in heels, but these shoes are INSANELY small for that size. My foot barely fit in the shoe, and the sole was very narrow in general. They are absolutely adorable, but really do NOT fit how they should. The ankle strap is also tiny for no apparent reason, I have pretty normal sized ankles and the strap barely fit around it. These shoes would only work for you if you have very small, dainty feet that are very, very narrow.

I do not see how anyone could stand to wear these shoes for more than 15 minutes. They are beautiful, but the toe strap is absolutely painful. I consider myself to have average width feet.

These shoes are very pretty and have to say for a heel of this style very comfortable foot bed. BUT...they felt as if they would fall apart the first wear. Heel felt weak and the strap where was attached to shoe was very "delicate" to me. Sadly will return.

I bought these to wear as a bridesmaid. I wanted strappy nude heels to wear with the short bridesmaid dress. I've worn uncomfortable shoes before. I've made the sacrifice for fashion. However, not these shoes. These were so uncomfortable, I had to change shoes immediately after the wedding ceremony. I had hoped they would work for more than one wedding. No way. It looks like I will be buying a new pair of strappy nude heels. These are super cute...and super uncomfortable.

I loved the look of this shoe and perfect for weddings or dressing up jeans, but as the other reviews have noted, the toe strap is incredibly tight. I did not try to jam my toes into them, and have returned them. Pretty shoe, but can't imagine actually wearing them for any amount of time.

I really loved these shoes when I saw them online, and I was so excited to get them! I had been looking for this exact style of shoe for a long time. But unfortunately when I tried them on they were so narrow that it made the shoe extremely uncomfortable. If they were a little wider I would have kept them!

These are super cute, but very uncomfortable. I wore them for my engagement photos and had to remove them between photos because they have no platform. I generally do not find Steve Madden shoes comfortable. I will keep them simply because they are cute.

Bought these shoes for a wedding I'm in. They are adorable but SO uncomfortable. After walking with them around the house for 5 minutes, I had to sit because my feet were already hurting. 5 minutes later I took them off because they hurt too much and my pinky toes had turned a deep red where they hit the strap. I wanted to love these so much and would have been perfect with my dress but there is just no way.

I got them both in black and nude but I am thinking of returning them. They are gorgeous but painful. That is such a shame because they are so light weight, the heel height is perfect and they are easy to walk in and look so pretty on your feet. They are also padded for extra comfort but they kill my poor toe. Perhaps if the strap was a soft leather they could work, but I do not think these will soften over time.

Poor quality. After two uses, the leather like strap had come unsecured and required supergluing.

These shoes were so cute and I wanted them to work. I'm normally a solid 7, I have normal width feet, and a normal toe box. The strap across the toes was so so so tight, I have no idea who these shoes were made for! I ended up trying a 7.5 in a department store before attempting an exchange, and the strap was just as tight. I would only recommend these to those that have narrow feet.

I have never tried on a more ill-fitting shoe in my life! I am a true 7.5 and hardly ever stray from my size. I also do not have a narrow or wide foot. These shoes, while exactly what I wanted/needed for an upcoming wedding, were the worst shoes I have ever tried on in my life. The toe strap was so tight that I barely had room to get my toes in there... I was having major toe cleavage and knew I wouldn't have lasted 15 minutes, with my toes like that! In addition, there was hardly and shoe for the (lack of) arch support to even be. Bad bad beddd!! Really wish these worked!! I don't know how they have such reviews. (and no I will not attach photos -- my feet have never looked so bad! My best friend was laughing so hard she started crying.... my feet have never been so embarrassed!!)