Customer Reviews Tahari Dottie

Very cute but VERY narrow in the toe and pointy. If you don't have really narrow feet you will see your toes through the fabric. I will have to return them.

Ordered a half-size below normal due to other reviews. Should've stuck with my normal size. Regardless, because it's a pointed shoe, the toe box felt cramped. My feet are a normal width and maybe these would've stretched and eventually been comfortable, but I wasn't willing to find out.

These are really great for multiple looks, they go equally well with work dresses or skinny jeans. They are very pointy so you have to like the wicked witch of the west look, which I happen to. My one complaint is although the first time I wore them I thought they were very comfy, the second time out I got blisters on my little toes.

I love these shoes especially with a cigarette trouser or pencil skirt. Get that retro look in a comfortable heel. Have had three pairs, heel wears out easily (at least for me, I walk a lot on concrete for work, but otherwise adore.

You need to reaaaaally love the pointy toe look to love these shoes. They were so pointy that they turned up a bit at the toe. A little much for me.

Runs small and narrow. I'm usually a 6.5 and this was small for me. Front is also very long and pointed - more so than other pointed tip heels.

I have bought this same shoe before in black and navy. this would have been my 3rd pair. I did not feel this shoe was comfortable. It was too tight by my toes. I do not have a wide foot either.

I particularly liked these because the fabric made them wearable year-round, and they were elegant looking on. Unfortunately they were very stiff, didn’t feel like they would ever be comfortable, and the heels slipped badly, even with different kinds of padding and grips so I returned them.

Love this show, but it runs small. I'm exchanging for half size larger.

These shoes are a perfect gray, the toe is extra pointy and the heel is small but unfortunately these killed my feet. The inside rubbed both of my feet on both sides. I ended up giving them to goodwill after wearing them twice all day at work hating life.

These are a very pretty shoe but not really made for a human foot. I love pointed toe pumps, but the forefoot space is so narrow that your foot almost has to fold in half to fit. I would think thank getting a bigger size might increase the width, but then the shoe would be so super long it would be hard to walk without tripping. Such a shame, but could have been designed more anatomically.

Looked nice but felt very tight. Did not order next size up so I cannot speak to whether this would have solved the issue

fit is very small. I'm a standard 9 and I would need to go up a half size at least, which of course is out of stock!

I love the look of these shoes. I typically wear a medium width shoe. These shoes were really narrow - had to return them.

I like a pointy black shoe but this is laughable. The toe is very long and pointy. I will be returning these.

Cute shoe but it runs very narrow. So I had to return it.

Actually pretty comfortable, especially for how pointy it is, but in the end the toe was just too long. I am short so maybe it would be okay on a taller person.

Beautiful shoe, but the hard design feature above the heal/below the ankle rubbed and did not feel like that could be broken in. Had to return.

I bought these in hopes of finding that elusive comfort and stylish factor. They are not a perfect solution - still rub my toes after walking in them for awhile and arch support is meh. The toe is really pointy, which on my big feet starts to look a little witchy. I do like that the toe box of these shoes come far enough up on your foot that you do not have to work to keep them on.

Great looking shoe, but one of the most uncomfortable I've every worn . . . way tight on baby toes! Can't wear them for more than an hour.

Somehow I just didn't understand how pointy these shoes were from the pictures. To me they were embarrassingly too pointy and I have to send them back

Beautiful pump love the color, I take a 6 1/2 to 7 and size 7 was too tight. My foot is a medium. Had to return :-) Trying a 7 1/2 hope it fits.

The shoe is extremely long but more important, very uncomfortable. It cut across the top of my foot and I wouldn't be able to stay in them for more than a few minutes. They are going back. The gray color, disappointing.

Super cute shoes but super narrow fit! I don’t even know if ordering a size up would help since they’re so narrow!! I love Tahari but I am very disappointed with the sizing on this shoe.