Customer Reviews To Boot New York Aidan

I purchased these shoes after having to return a pair of Magnannis, they were too small. I am a size 15 and these babies fit perfectly. I usually prefer a little more flair or character to my oxfords, but these are a very sleek and professional shoe. a hair darker than the photo, but as I wear them I'm sure some wear and tear will lighten them up a bit. Very nice, overall sleek and uniform look.

To Boot always wins when it comes to style, quality, and comfort.

A beautiful shoe. Everything I expected and more! Was an option and I chose the other one.

Chose Aidan over Magnanni Bonete because it appears more sleek from the top and has softer leather. Unfortunately, I couldn't find a perfect fit. 9.5 was too narrow, so I ended up going with a 10, which fit in width, but is slightly long. I have another TBNY cap-toe that fits perfectly in 9.5.

An excellent captoe-style oxford. And this is actually an oxford. This is the second pair of TBNY shoes I have owned; I have a pair of TBNY's "Brandon's" in brown, too. The Aidan has very soft leather (the Brandon, in contrast, has a slightly stiffer type of leather). I've only worn the shoes about a half dozen times and they feel pretty much broken in. I think the sizing is pretty much spot on. I have a pair of English oxfords which are pricier and Goodyear-welted but the Aidan stands up pretty well.

Fit perfect right out of the box and comfort was awesome. No wear in time required. The only negative is that the color is darker than the pics online.

I bought a pair of these and in three months holes in leather souls and the upper leather has cracks in the leather. Italian made, more like china made. I paid full retail and online they are half the price. I feel these shoes are cheap. I would be better off buying a shoe for 50 dollars at Walmart that hold up better than this. If there was a lemon law on shoes, they would be replaced in secs.