Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

I saw these on my friend and immediately came home and ordered a pair for myself. Quality that you expect from Frye they are a nice leather and have soft insoles. I ordered the cognac color--a warm brown that can go with almost everything. These are comfortable, great for running errands, going out to dinner, wearing to work. They have the easiness of a sneaker without the casualness so they are more versatile to wear. I highly recommend them!

It's a beautiful, well-made shoe. After two days of wear, my toes still feel pinched. I'm hopeful, though. My feet are an average, ordinary medium width, ordinary proportions.

I sized up a half size. My normal size was a bit short. The half size up is perfect! Since they're leather, they'll definitely stretch and soften over time. But, they're super comfy right out of the box!

This is my second pair of these shoes + I absolutely love them!! They are one of the most comfortable pairs of flats I've ever owned. I've had a couple of foot surgeries on one foot + am able to wear these shoes without orthotics or extra support for the whole day due to the amazingly comfortable memory foam in the bottom. I'm solidly like an 8.25 size (so frustrating!) - and I have both a size 8 in the nubuck suede, and now an 8.5 in the black leather. The nubuck did stretch slightly as expected, but I think the 8.5 are overall a better size for my finicky feet. Can't say enough good things about these shoes - I'll probably be buying a 3rd pair pretty soon!