Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

Great shoe, but requires some breaking in. Has held up well though.

I really like the look of this casual shoe and found I could wear them comfortably right out of the box with no break in period necessary. They do not flop or wear on my heel and the bottom provides a bit of stability and traction. The leather is quality and does not crack or crease with wear. The white bottom does tend to get dirty easily, but I use magic eraser to keep it looking clean. My foot is average to narrow in width, so this style fit me well, but if your foot is wide, they may be too tight. I love this style so much, I’m going for another color. As always, Zappos shipping was tremendously fast and accurate!

These are very stylish! Look great. A little narrow in the toebox. I hope they will be comfortable for longer wear on my trip. They are comfortable for shorter periods.

SO cute! The leather is so soft. No breaking in period at all. Nice and minimal.

These were comfy and fit well, but I personally prefer the cut of the Ivy slip to this one, so returned them. One thing I would caution regarding any Frye slip: the uppers, since they are leather, last indefinitely. However, since the soles are rubber they wear out sooner than you would wish, hope or expect for their price point. This sneaker will not last through more than a season or so of wear, which I found disappointing. That said, I also really loved my Ivy slips so I took a deep breath and bought them again this year, but I'm going to look for one that is a little less spendy or a little more enduring.

The leather on one shoe looked damaged, like a crease was permanently across the front of the shoe, from toe to top of shoe. Very distracting. I could not justify the expense of the shoe

This is a great show but the zappo return system isn’t working for me. I’ve tried for a month to return this shoe. I am not getting a return label for what was once a very simple process.

Absolutely love the style and fit. Was not so happy with the color. Ordered gray, but almost looked purple. May find another color!

How do I love thee? Let me count the ways. You are soft (but not too soft,) well-made, stylish, and comfortable right out of the box. I usually wear an 8 in flats, so I ordered an 8. They were just a little too long and I was afraid once they stretched, they'd be falling off my feet. So I ordered a 7.5. They are a little snug over the toe box but the length is perfect. I can already feel them adjusting to my feet. I might order a spring color. Gorgeous and fun, all at once.

Cute shoe but it was too wide in the heel and long the side of the foot for me.

These shoes are stylish and comfortable. I usually wear a 9.5 but the 9 fit better. They seemed snug at first but the leather stretches just a bit and molds to your foot like a glove. I highly recommend these shoes!

Got these in the black leather. Love them. Very well made. High end look. The leather super soft, and the lining is superb. Reminds me of the shoes made years back. Can't find shoes this well made anymore. My only complaint and for me, it is a big one. No cushioning. flat flat So, They had to go back. hated to see them go. Oh, and they fit so well, no room to add any other type insert to add more cushion. I tried. I usually wear an 8 but these were 8.5 and fit perfect.