Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

cute shoe but not fitting my foot well. 10.5 is my sweet spot and more manufacturers should offer this length.

I have another pair of Melanie's I have loved very much. They are always snug at first, but stretch to be comfortable. However I am disappointed in the Cognac color. It is a lot more red than I was expecting. I will need to return them.

The Frye Melanie slip ons are so very attractive. Comfy slip on & lightweight. Great with linen dress/pants & jeans.

Love these! The white leather is perfect for work and they can be dressed down, too, for the weekends. The leather is very soft and has a lot of give so it is very comfortable to wear. I can even fit a pair of arch support insoles, which isn’t always possible.

Sorry to report that with older feet the soft leather did not provide the need support

Might fit a wider foot, nice shoe

My feet are too narrow, felt on the wider side

These are a go-to slip on for those days when comfort overrides everything else. Bought them for years

So comfy!!

Very comfortable from the moment I put them on. Very stylish. They will be an integral part of my wardrobe.

Material feels awesome. Will wear them out!

So comfortable right from the start!

Felt incredibly comfortable as soon as I put them on!

gd

This is my second pair of the Melanie slip on. ( Because I love to slip it on.) It fits true to my size (6.5B); and it's the shoe that worked with everything last summer. It is elegant with a thin lightly ribbed rubber non slip sole. So it works with jeans, pants, and even a summer dress. I should mention I live in the country but also wore them around NYC last week.

These shoes are a perfect fit. The soft leather is so comfortable and they are very stylish. They are very lightweight. The perfect travel shoe.

Just feels good.

Super comfy, no break in needed, wears like gloves! Best for warmer fall days when socks are not required. Will be my go to style for casual slip on from now on!

Absolutely love these shoes! NYL complaint is that there is basically no arch support. They are super comfortable, look great and I have had many compliments. I just don’t wear them for long periods of time.

True to size. Perfect with jeans and a sweater! Classic look, great material!

Hard to find but worth the wait! Beautiful leather, perfect fit from the start and so supportive an comfortable all day. So worth the price they last forever.

I love the way they look and the leather is beautiful!

Slipped these shoes on right away when they arrived. They are surprisingly comfortable out of the box--the leather is soft and didn't really require "breaking in" like some shoes. As with any new pair of shoes I had some rubbing/"hot spots" when I wore them the first couple of times, but that subsided pretty quickly. I'm happy with these shoes and their versatility!

The shoe felt comfortable right out of the box. A rounded toe would be a little more comfortable but it's fine as is. It is uniquely stylish. Love the color. I would recommend this shoe, particularly to those who love high quality leather.

I had purchased this shoe in “cognac”, and had been searching for this grey. Zappos was out of it in my size, but had a return on it. Many compliments on both colors!