Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

I love Melanie and have had it in the antiqued yellow for several seasons. I wanted it another color and chose the antiqued grey. Unfortunately, the actual color is a greyish lavender or pink (is that mauve). It's so off, that I'm sending them back.

Stylish shoe with soft leather. Unfortunately, the toe area is too narrow even with my narrow foot. Wanted to keep but had to return. I hope Frye designs the same style without the narrow, pointy toe.

I really loved these shoes at first, but sadly like some previous reviews my shoes have stretched out after a month. The leather is pulling from the rubber after moderate to light wear. These shoes are extremely comfortable and high quality leather but lack on durability, which is sad given the high price tag.

I wanted to like this shoe, but it hurt so bad. Was very narrow in the toe area. Maybe I needed a bigger size, but I didn’t love it enough to exchange.

Really wanted to love these shoes but the toe box is just too tight. Crushed my big toes! Everything else seemed just fine.

These shoes run very small.

Limping after wearing them one hour. Too bad, cute. Zappos gave great customer service, though!

I had high hopes for these. The shape of the toe looked terrible on my feet. There was no arch support so IMO, they were not comfortable at all. They looked and felt awkward. Maybe I could gave sized down, or chose another color but for the price and discomfort, I decided to return them.

I always were a size 7 but would need a 7 1/2 or 8 in this shoe

These are very cute and streamlined so I was hoping they'd work for me. Unfortunately, I have wide feet and these seem to run small and narrow so that even sizing up by half a size didn't help.

I wanted to like these shoes, I really did. The color name "Pewter" lured me in. Upon arrival I wore them around the house and looked in the mirror and laughed out looked. No "pewter" there the shoes look like you have wrapped your feet in aluminum foil! If you like that look, buy, although they run small so size up if you are a half size. Sadly for me I returned to Zappos. Love Zappos and Frye, this pair was just a huge fashion don't.

For me these were very tight in the toe box and I have the Dylan slip on and two pair of the Melissa boots in same size. Quality and look was nice but not going to try larger size because my ankle is narrow and would likely slip in that area.

I'm not sure why this shoe gets such high marks for arch support. I think there is none at all. I ordered 3 colors so I could audition them at home before deciding. My favored color was out of stock. I ordered the pink nubuck, cognac and the red. I was surprised to see that all the colors has a nice mellow quality to them and they all looked great with more pants and skirts than I would have imagined. It is a very comfortable, very flattering shoe, and classy for what it is. Just zero arch support. I wear an 8 in Keens, and a 7.5 in other shoes, but I will need this in a 7. I also have what's called a "low volume" foot, so clogs ands slip-ons can be challenging, but these are fine in that department.

These are the most uncomfortable flats I’ve ever had. Zero cushion, too wide, and just terrible. I tried really hard to get used to them because they are cute, but just 30 minutes in them and I hurt. For perspective, I can be hours in flat flip flops. This is just a horrible shoe cobbled by the devil himself.

I was confused by this pair of shoes! I own other pairs of Melanie slip-ons, & have always been happy with them. This pair of shoes seemed long in the toe bed, which caused them to look somewhat lumpy and pre-owned. They did not seem to be the expected quality of a Frye shoe. I was disappointed, & had to return.

Not for me, disappointed!

I'm always looking for an upscale casual shoe for travel and weekend outings. This is a super cute casual slip on.. A+ on style. Unfortunately, no support what so ever. Unfortunately these will go back. I'm still on the hunt!