Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

I was looking for a comfortable traveling shoe. This shoe fits the bill. I followed the advice of several reviewers and ordered a 1/2 size up. Perfect! The leather is so very soft and there seems to be a good bit of inside padding which I need. Great look on your feet. I have a medium foot but a little on the narrow side. This is going to be my go to shoe for everything! Thank you Zappos....we had a few “send backs” before getting the perfect one.

I love these shoes/sneakers. I have thin and sensitive skin so wearing a flat like this usually leads to blisters on my heels. Wore all day today and no blisters, no sore spots - great shoes.

Wish this came in a narrow width or a 10.5. If you are a 10.5 and think you can size up, this shoe may be too big/wide for you. I think a half size between 10 and 11 or a narrow option would be a helpful addition. Otherwise, it's a stylish, cute, well-made shoe and I wish it worked for me!

These are super cute! I had been looking at black leather slip-on sneakers and these are a little more stylist and feminine than the rest, in my opinion. The toe has a little point. The white rubber is relatively small. I think they are classy looking and pretty comfortable right out of the box.

I wanted something for airport travel. Easy on, easy off. To simplify getting thru airport security. They definitely fit they bill! They are also very comfortable for all the walking throughout the airport... no need for time to break them in. Super comfy & cute! I get compliments every time I wear them!

usually wear a 10. I had to look at the size on box thinking they sent me the wrong size. They didn't much too small for me. Sorry.

I was hesitant to spend the money on these, but I'm glad I did. They are super comfortable right out of the box. The grey color goes with everything, so I wear them everyday. They go with pants, cropped pants, skirts and dresses. I wear a 7 to 7 1/2 and got the 7s. Fit is true to size. I wish I could afford to buy more colors!

These have become my new favorite shoes! Can dress up or down and no uncomfortable break in time. Considering getting another pair!!

These shoes are fantastic! They are very soft leather, have great support and are extremely comfortable. Mine have been worn when walking all day and were just great. A favorite shoe.....

This shoe looks used. The sole is dirty, as are the white edges around the front and back. It also has a scratch on the top right shoe. I love the style and it fits very comfortably, probably because it has been tried on or worn before. It is just not clean or new.

Thought I would love these shoes, but turns out I just like them a lot. A nice-looking shoe that will work well with casual outfits. I think the size runs a little big. I wear a 9, they are just a tad long and a little wide, not so much that my foot slides around, but just not a perfect fit. They are very light and flexible, with a cushioned footbed. But not a lot of arch support.

I always have a little problem with Frye - their toe box narrows and pushes the toes together. I ordered two sizes, 8.5 and 9. I am between sizes often. the 9's were way too loose and the 8.5 a tad tight in the toe. I kept them anyway because they are a very handsome shoe. I've worn them a few times for no more than 5 hours. At the end they began to feel pretty tight in the toes. so will wear them for short periods of time - never all day. And who knows, maybe they will stretch out a bit.

Love the color and look. Unfortunately, the size was a little larger than expected. I run between a 6.5 and 7. I hesitated ordering a 6.5 thinking it might be too snug. But I figured leather will usually stretch out somewhat. When shoes arrived they were much looser than I anticipated. My hope is that as I wear them in warmer climates (which is why I purchased them) it will accommodate my feet as they swell with the heat. They really are cute though and the toe which I also worried about being too snug is fine.

Run narrow and they kept slipping off my feet My toes felt very squished. Sizing up didnt help.

The leather is beautiful and I loved the style, a little less white sole showing is a refreshing change. But the fit was off on my foot The heel was loose to the point I felt I would walk out of the shoes and the toe box a bit snug so not particularly comfortable, If I had kept them I am sure the supple leather would have stretched in both toe and heel so they did go back.

I am always a 6.5, after reading reviews decided to order a 6.5. It's too small by quite a bit. I don't think they will soften and fit me so I am returning... may try 1/2 size up but I am afraid they will slip in the heal. They are quite lovely, though!

The fit did not feel like a true Frye construct. This pair seemed cheaply made and was not as appealing as I'd felt my previous Frye purchases have been. The color is gorgeous, however.

Squeezed my toes enough to trigger my neuroma, so after a short time of wearing they became uncomfortable. I have fairly narrow feet, so these were notably narrow. Not to mention the color, which is definitely NOT gray. Sent them back.

Loved the look of these shoes. I tried 3 times to find the right fit. 8,5 too small. 9 too large. I the tried a different color hoping the leather would fit different. I had to return all

I loved the look and feel of the materials used, however the toe box was too narrow and the instep area ‘gapped’, making the shoe appear too wide. I wish they had worked as I absolutely loved the style and quality of these shoes....i tend to have a narrow foot, and slip-one are my biggest challenge to fit.

These are beautiful shoes, soft leather, just as pictured. Unfortunately they have NO support. I have 2 pair of treasured Frye boots, but these have to go back. I wore them once and love the look but they just don't work for my feet. Thank you Zappos.

great looking shoes. Wanted to wear them as soon as they arrived. Actually did. Loved the style between a ballet and slip-on tennis shoe. The box toe was super tight and I have slender feet. I kept in my from a review that breaking them in would make them more comfortable. It stretched slightly and I just went to go run a quick errand and got blisters on the both small toes of each foot. Ouch! Couldn’t wait to take them off. I guess I will keep them because no one wants a return with blister fluids. I wouldn’t. Will wear around the house with socks and keeping my fingers crossed that it will get better. So love your style shoes, but you hurt. Sad.

Wear size 9 Ordered size 9 Shoe was overall BIG. Like swimming in it too big. Support for your arches or soles is non-existent in this shoe!!! Yet, I did like the shoe. Because the leather is beautiful, and the color deeply saturated. I may order a size down, and add inserts for the support the shoe is missing.

I wanted these shoes badly. Were too narrow in toe box and a bit short. Exchanged for 1/2 size up. Length now perfect but toe box is still small, so back they go. I’m sad: they are cute and flexible; the leather soft and supple. Just won’t work for my toes. If you have narrow feet, go for it!!

I loved these for the first few weeks. They quickly stretched and are wearing out on the bottom already. They are almost unwearable and want to slip off. For the price, I’d think they would have lasted longer.