Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

NOt made for someone with bunions as advertised

I really liked these and had previously ordered the distressed metallic in the same size, 7. Those fit perfectly in a 7 which is my size. The black ones were are least a size smaller so I am returning them. Not sure why this happened. Really disappointed. Its an attractive well made shoe.

toe box is narrow and small. i have ingrown issues in my big toes and this would be too painful to keep. I figured that out thankfully in the first 3.5 seconds i wore them on the carpet , and then back in the box they went. a half size larger would have been slipping off the heels. kindof ugly orthodic old lady look to them considering it's funky fresh frye. i thought the leather would be more distressed and edgy indicating a more millennial look. i have ingrown issues but these are a hard no looking like nursing home skids. blah. fail.

I bought these shoes in grey and absolutely loved them right out of the box. I am a teacher and being on my feet all day, it is important to me to find shoes to wear that are comfortable and stylish. Unfortunately, the heels developed holes after 28 days of wear. Considering how much they cost, this is unacceptable and does not represent Frye quality. I own 12 pairs of Frye shoes and boots and this is the only pair that I have had such a disappointing result with. I reached out to Zappos and received a prompt reply to return or exchange the shoes, which is greatly appreciated.

If you have wide feet and a high arch, run away. Super tight - couldn't even get foot in. Good looking though.